Sanders' Convention Speech Attacked by NYT for Advocating Popular Policies

Elsie Carson-Holt

New York Times deputy opinion editor Patrick Healy (8/20/24) described Sen. Bernie Sanders' speech to the Democratic National Convention as an attempt to "make policy proposals that put [Kamala] Harris in a big-government vise, binding (or pushing) her in a direction that a lot of moderates do not want to go."

Healy depicted Sanders as

grasp[ing] the lectern with both hands as he unfurled one massive government program idea after another in a progressive policy reverie that must have been music to the ears of every democratic socialist at the United Center.

New York Times deputy opinion editor Patrick Healey (8/20/24): "On Tuesday night, Sanders put Harris on the hot seat."

Healey followed the standard New York Times line (FAIR.org, 7/26/24) that progressive candidates need to move to the right to win—and scorned Sanders for ignoring that advice: "Harris needs some of those swing-state moderates if she’s going to win the presidency, but the electoral math didn’t seem to be on Sanders’s mind."

Strangely, though, the specific policies that Healey mentioned Sanders as promoting don't seem to be particularly unpopular, with moderates or anyone else. Rather, opinion polls find them to be supported by broad majorities:

• "Overturning Citizens United": Three-fourths of survey respondents (Center for Public Integrity, 5/10/18) say that they support a constitutional amendment t0 overturn the 2010 Supreme Court decision that allows the wealthy to spend unlimited amounts of money on elections. In the same survey, 60% said reducing the influence of big campaign donors is “very important.” According to the Pew Research Center (5/8/18), 77% of the public says “there should be limits on the amount of money individuals and organizations” can spend on political campaigns.
• "Making healthcare 'a human right' for all Americans": A 2020 Pew Research Center poll (9/29/20) found that “63% of US adults say the government has the responsibility to provide healthcare coverage for all.” Another Pew poll (1/23/23) reported 57% agreeing that it's "the responsibility of the federal government to make sure all Americans have healthcare coverage."
• "Raising the minimum wage to a 'living wage'”: According to the Pew Research Center (4/22/21), 62% of Americans want the federal minimum wage raised to $15 an hour. (Most of the remainder wanted the minimum wage increased by a lesser amount.) According to the think tank Data for Progress (4/26/24), 86% of likely voters do not think the current federal minimum wage is enough for a decent quality of life.
• "Raising teachers’ salaries": The 2023 PDK poll found that 67% of respondents support increasing local teacher salaries by raising property taxes. The AP/NORC poll (4/18) reported that "78% of Americans say teachers in this country are underpaid."
• "Cutting prescription drug costs in half": A poll from 2023 by Data for Progress found that 73% of all likely voters supported Biden administration initiatives allowing Medicare to negotiate lower prescription drug costs. Health policy organization KFF (8/21/23) reported that 88% of adults support “limiting how much drug companies can increase the price for prescription drugs each year to no more than the rate of inflation.”

Back in 2015, when Sanders was running for president, Healy co-wrote an article for the Times (5/31/15; Extra!, 7–8/15) that declared him "unelectable," in part because he supported "far higher taxes on the wealthy." But raising taxes on the rich turns out to be consistently popular in opinion polls (FAIR.org, 4/20/15).

What we're learning is that progressive policy proposals are deeply unpopular—with the New York Times' deputy opinion editor.

ACTION ALERT: You can send a message to the New York Times at [email protected]. Please remember that respectful communication is the most effective. Feel free to leave a copy of your communication in the comments thread.