[[link removed]]

VANCE’S PAEAN TO BLOOD AND SOIL – JD VANCE DISMISSES THE AMERICAN
IDEA  
[[link removed]]


 

Jeff Jacoby
July 23, 2024
Boston Globe
[[link removed]]


*
[[link removed]]
*
[[link removed]]
*
*
[[link removed]]

_ Ours is a nation built upon a set of ideas — ideas not rooted in
bloodlines and burial plots but in values and ideals. Anyone who
doesn’t understand something so fundamental about the United States
is unfit for high office. _

Senator JD Vance spoke during the Republican National Convention, in
Milwaukee on July 17., Photo: Paul Sancya/AP // Boston Globe

 

I don’t much care for JD Vance’s MAGA politics. I’m not a fan of
his anti-free-trade protectionism, his America First
near-isolationism, his blood-and-soil nationalism, his scapegoating of
immigrants, his disdain for liberal democratic mores, his repudiation
of limited-government conservatism, or his sycophantic embrace of a
Donald Trump he used to describe as “noxious,”
“reprehensible,” an “idiot,” and “cultural heroin.”
Vance’s speech to the Republican National Convention in Milwaukee
last Wednesday was well delivered, but even a Periclean delivery
couldn’t compensate for misguided and harmful ideas.

One passage in his speech struck me as especially benighted.

”You know, one of the things that you hear people say sometimes is
that America is an idea,” Vance said.

”To be clear, America was indeed founded on brilliant ideas, like
the rule of law and religious liberty. Things written into the fabric
of our Constitution and our nation. But America is not just an idea.
It is a group of people with a shared history and a common future. It
is, in short, a nation.”

He continued: “Now, it is part of that tradition, of course, that we
welcome newcomers. But when we allow newcomers into our American
family, we allow them on our terms. That’s the way we preserve the
continuity of this project from 250 years past to hopefully 250 years
in the future.”

To illustrate what he means by allowing newcomers to become Americans
“on our terms,” Vance related that when he proposed to his future
wife Usha, the daughter of immigrants from India, he emphasized to her
his attachment to his family’s “cemetery plot on a mountainside in
Eastern Kentucky.” He wanted her to know that in marrying him,
“that’s what she was getting.” His family’s connection to
ancestral property, Vance told the convention delegates, goes to the
essence of what it means to be American. In other words, the people
among whom he grew up derive their American identity, above all, from
the _soil_ on which their forbears settled. “This is their home,
and it will be their children’s home, and they would die fighting to
protect it,” Vance said. “That is the source of America’s
greatness.”

Then he said this:

”Now that’s not just an idea, my friends. That’s not just a set
of principles. Even though the ideas and the principles are great,
that is a homeland. That is our homeland. People will not fight for
abstractions, but they will fight for their home.”

Of course America is the homeland of people who have lived here for
generations. Of course there are millions of Americans who feel bound
to that homeland by their “shared history.” But much of what makes
the United States so extraordinary is that for more than two centuries
it has also been the homeland of millions of people — immigrants and
the children of immigrants — with no lengthy family or property ties
in America. At the heart of Americanness is _not_ blood or soil but
the embrace of fundamental principles and beliefs. Vance is wrong.
America’s greatness is rooted precisely in the ideas that he regards
as secondary. His wife’s American identity does not inhere in the
burial plot of the family she married into. It is bound up, rather, in
the worldview her parents adopted when they left their native India
and put down roots in America.

This was a point that Ronald Reagan made frequently, including in his
very last speech as president
[[link removed]].

On Jan. 19, 1989, in a final ceremony to present the Presidential
Medal of Freedom, Reagan said he wanted to make “an observation
about a country which I love.” That observation, simply stated yet
profound, isolated a key truth about the United States. “You can go
to live in France, but you cannot become a Frenchman,” Reagan said,
quoting a letter from a correspondent. “You can go to live in
Germany or Turkey or Japan, but you cannot become a German, a Turk, or
a Japanese. But anyone, from any corner of the Earth, can come to live
in America and become an American.”

How does a person become an American? By taking on American
principles, above all those enshrined in the Declaration of
Independence — that we are created equal and endowed from birth with
the rights to life and liberty. At the heart of “American
exceptionalism”
[[link removed]] is the
recognition that full-fledged membership in our nation — unlike in
France, Germany, Turkey, or Japan — is not a matter of birth, blood,
ancestry, or soil. America is the embodiment of certain _ideas_, and
to be fully American one need only pledge allegiance to those
principles.

The Republican Party used to celebrate American exceptionalism.
But Trump explicitly rejects the concept
[[link removed]],
so it stands to reason that his running mate, having jettisoned so
many of his principles to refashion himself as the MAGA heir apparent,
would turn his back on this one too.

Even so, how can Vance — who enlisted in the Marines after 9/11 —
claim with a straight face that “people will not fight for
abstractions”? What does that even mean? People have been fighting
for “abstractions” — for ideas and principles — for millennia.
Certainly Americans have.

What was the American Revolution, after all, if not a war fought for
abstractions? The colonists were in no danger of losing their land or
their homes. They took up arms because they wanted independence, an
end to monarchy, the right to govern themselves, no taxation without
representation — abstractions all.

And what was the Civil War if not a fight for “abstractions”?
Abraham Lincoln led the nation in what began as a war to preserve the
Union, then became a war to end slavery. In his matchless address at
the Gettysburg battlefield, Lincoln laid out in his first two
sentences the transcendent abstraction for which the Union fought:

”Four score and seven years ago our fathers brought forth on this
continent a new nation, conceived in Liberty, and dedicated to the
proposition that all men are created equal. Now we are engaged in a
great civil war, testing whether that nation, or any nation so
conceived and so dedicated, can long endure.”

During World War II, Frank Capra produced a series of seven films
called “Why We Fight.”
[[link removed]] Its
purpose was to explain to the American public why the nation was at
war with Germany, Italy, and Japan.

The first documentary in the series
[[link removed]] put
the fundamental question front and center: “What put us into
uniform, ready to engage the enemy on every continent and every
ocean?” The answer came at once: “This is a fight between a free
world and a slave world.” Over and above every other consideration,
the bloodiest foreign war ever waged by the United States was fought
for the preservation of freedom, democratic liberalism, and Western
civilization — the greatest “abstractions” of them all.

In his quest for power, Vance has repudiated views and values he once
expressed with seeming conviction. But while Vance may have remade
himself into an unrestrained Trumpian for reasons of political
expediency, the ideas at the core of the American experience remain
unchanged. Ours is a nation built upon a set of ideas — ideas not
rooted in bloodlines and burial plots but in values and ideals. Anyone
who doesn’t understand something so fundamental about the United
States is unfit for high office.

* J.D. Vance
[[link removed]]
* GOP
[[link removed]]
* MAGA
[[link removed]]
* Republican Party
[[link removed]]
* Donald Trump
[[link removed]]
* 2024 Elections
[[link removed]]
* Fascism
[[link removed]]
* traditional values
[[link removed]]
* Blood and Soil
[[link removed]]
* Ronald Reagan
[[link removed]]

*
[[link removed]]
*
[[link removed]]
*
*
[[link removed]]

 

 

 

INTERPRET THE WORLD AND CHANGE IT

 

 

Submit via web
[[link removed]]

Submit via email
Frequently asked questions
[[link removed]]
Manage subscription
[[link removed]]
Visit xxxxxx.org
[[link removed]]

Twitter [[link removed]]

Facebook [[link removed]]

 




[link removed]

To unsubscribe, click the following link:
[link removed]