The Hate Crime and Public Order (Scotland) Act cam into force this week, with critics warning that the new law enables censorship of political dissent

Logo

This week, Scotland’s new hate speech law came into effect with a tidal wave of criticism from the likes of JK Rowling and Elon Musk.

The Hate Crime and Public Order (Scotland) Act 2021 creates a new offence of communicating material that a ‘reasonable person’ would consider to be ‘threatening’ or ‘abusive’ with the intent of stirring up hatred based on age, disability, religion, sexual orientation, transgender identity or being intersex. The maximum penalty is a seven year prison sentence.

It goes without saying that nobody should ever face abuse based on immutable characteristics. Nevertheless, it is dangerous to criminalise speech on such an ambiguous and subjective basis. Who is this magical ‘reasonable person’? What does it mean to say you have been ‘threatening’ or ‘stirred up hatred’? This law gives Police Scotland and the Scottish courts the unenviable task of deciding these questions.

The law invites vexatious complaints. Police Scotland has confirmed that JK Rowling will not be investigated for misgendering, but over 3,000 complaints have been received since the start of the week. Even if there are relatively few prosecutions, these complaints could still be recorded as ‘non-crime hate incidents’, undermining people’s ability to get jobs in future.

Particularly concerning is that, unlike many equivalents, the law may apply to private conversations, not just public pronouncements. This means a disgruntled family member or acquaintance or someone who overhears a private conversation is invited to submit complaints to the police and may even do so anonymously.

Taken together, the mere existence of this law on the statute books will have a chilling effect on debate about controversial topics like gender and immigration. Censorship not only undermines the ability to have necessary and important debates, but it also takes away our more fundamental ability to hear ideas and choose what we believe. Any law that means arresting, convicting, and jailing people merely for expressing an idea without any linked action is intolerable in a free society.

This is not to say we should let the UK Government off the hook. Despite rhetoric about free speech, there has been a consistent failure to reform laws that undermine it and the introduction of new problematic laws – from Section 127 of the Communications Act 2003 to the Online Safety Bill.

Perhaps the one bright spot this week is that finally people are taking notice. The IEA has been raising the alarm bell about the Scottish hate crime law since 2021 ([link removed]) and has talked about the importance of free speech for many decades ([link removed]) . We will continue highlighting the dangers posed by these laws to a free society.

Matthew Lesh

IEA Director of Public Policy and Communications

Dictating words: The Culture-Control Left and the war against free speech ([link removed])

Cultural Affairs Fellow Marc Glendening

A worrying trend… Scotland’s beefed-up censorship laws are just the latest in a series of measures which have undermined the right to freedom of speech.
[link removed]
[link removed]


** IEA In Conversation with Dominic Frisby on Money, Tax, and Culture ([link removed])
------------------------------------------------------------

Next week, Executive Director Tom Clougherty will host a conversation with comedian and writer Dominic Frisby on money, tax, and culture.

Dominic (“mercurially witty” – The Spectator) has an odd double life as financial writer and comedian. He is MoneyWeek’s main commentator on gold, commodities, currencies and cryptocurrencies. He has a popular newsletter on Substack, the Flying Frisby ([link removed]) and has authored three books: Daylight Robbery: How Tax Shaped Our Past and Will Change Our Future ([link removed]) ; Bitcoin: the Future of Money?
([link removed]) And Life After the State ([link removed]) .

Date: Tuesday, 9 April

Time: 17:30 - 19:30

Location: IEA, 2 Lord North Street, SW1P 3LA
RSVP ([link removed])

Coming Up Next… ([link removed])

Later this month, the IEA Book Club will host Professor of Finance at London Business School Alex Edmans to discuss his upcoming book May Contain Lies: How Stories, Statistics, and Studies Exploit Our Biases—And What We Can Do about It ([link removed])

Date: Tuesday, 23 April

Time: 17:30 - 19:30

Location: IEA Offices, 2 Lord North Street, SW1P 3LA
[link removed]
RSVP ([link removed])

IEA Latest.
[link removed]

Attitudes to the NHS are finally catching up with reality ([link removed])

Editorial Director Kristian Niemietz, City AM ([link removed])

Lagging indicators… The NHS has always produced sub-standard outcomes, but the British public are beginning to question the system itself for the first time.
[link removed]

Germany is right to not fear the reefer ([link removed])

Communications Officer Harrison Griffiths, CapX ([link removed])

Small victories… The tide of drug policy liberalisation has not swept the world as expected. But Germany’s legalisation of cannabis this week shows that the spark is still there.
[link removed]

How do Nations Escape Poverty? Lessons from free market economies ([link removed])

Matthew Lesh interviews historian and author Rainer Zitelmann, IEA YouTube ([link removed])

The magic formula… Culture, technology, and institutions all play a key role in allowing countries to escape the poverty that defines most of human history.
[link removed]

Let’s be honest, social media isn’t driving a teen mental health crisis ([link removed])

Matthew Lesh, City AM ([link removed])

Post hoc ergo propter hoc… The evidence for social media driving a mental health crisis looks thin under scrutiny.
[link removed]

Outrageous Attempts to Limit Smokers' Rights | The Swift Half with Snowdon ([link removed])

Head of Lifestyle Economics Christopher Snowdon interviews Forest Director Simon Clarke, IEA YouTube ([link removed])

Adults infantilised… The government’s anti-tobacco crusade is, at its heart, an attack on the right of adults to make decisions about their own lifestyle.

IEA Insider.


** Sixth Form Future Thought Leaders
------------------------------------------------------------

This week, the IEA hosted 28 sixth form students for seminars on economic policy, political philosophy, and careers. They discussed money creation in a modern economy, classical liberalism, economic inequality and free market approaches to climate change. On their final day, the students participated in a debate moderated by Education Coordinator Matthew Prescod and judged by Senior Education Fellow Dr Stephen Davies, considering issues like central bank independence and freedom of speech. We look forward to hosting the second group of sixth form Future Thought Leaders next week!


** Vinson Internship Launched
------------------------------------------------------------

This week, Education Coordinator Megi Cara and Director of the Vinson Centre Dr Juan Castañada launched the Vinson Internship. Kicking off their first day, interns delved into the history of classical liberalism with Managing Editor Daniel Freeman. Prof Martin Ricketts led a session on the distinctions between economics and political economy.
[link removed] [link removed] [link removed] [link removed] [link removed] [link removed] [link removed]
Logo

© 2024 Institute of Economic Affairs. All rights reserved.
You are receiving this email from the Institute of Economic Affairs
Registered in England 755502, Charity No. CC/235 351, Limited by Guarantee

View in browser ([link removed]) | Update ([link removed]) | Unsubscribe ([link removed])