This excerpt is taken from Think Liberty Idaho. It is a great rundown on how the library bill has transformed over the last several sessions from good to worthless.
The Transformation of Idaho's "Library Bill"
2022 - H666 would have removed the exemption afforded to schools and libraries to distribute harmful materials to minors. Senator Winder refused the bill a Senate hearing after it passed 51-14 (5 absent) in the House. Yes votes on H666 included; Furniss, McCann, Yamamoto and Hartgen (now a Senator) who all voted Nay on 2023's library bills.
2023- H139 would have allowed a civil action up to $10,000 against a school or public library that disseminated pornographic, harmful material to minors. This bill was killed in House Education Committee by Chair Julie Yamamoto and Vice Chair Lori McCann.
2023- H314 would have dropped the civil action of H139 to $2,500. This bill passed both the House & Senate and was vetoed by Governor Brad Little. The vote to override the veto in the House failed by ONE. Representatives that voted against overriding the Governor's veto; Bundy, Cheatum, Dixon (24), Furniss, Garner, Lanting, McCann, Mickelsen, Nelsen, Petzke, Raymond, Sauter, Wroten, Yamamoto.
2024- H384 would have required 30 day written notification to the school or library to allow for the moving of the pornographic material prior to a $250 civil action. This bill was set for debate on the House floor but was pulled at the last minute in order to present a compromise bill with Senator Geoff Schroeder (who voted against H314 in 2023).
2024- S1289 This compromise bill of Rep. Jaron Crane (D12) and Senator Geoff Schroeder (D8) requires parents to submit a relocation form to the school or library which then will go before a Material Review Committee. Only after the Material Review Committee refuses the relocation of the book in question can the parent move on to a $250 civil action. This bill also removes from the definition of obscene material "The quality of any material or of any performance, or of any description or representation, in whatever form, which, as a whole, has the dominant effect of substantially arousing sexual desires in persons under the age of 18."