February 11, 2024
Read in Browser [[link removed]]
POWERED BY
The big day is upon us, which also means, sadly, dear reader, my run of Super Bowl–week newsletters has expired with this morning’s edition. For my last go at this, I take a look at the debate about whether hosting the Super Bowl is truly worth it for Las Vegas. On one side are boosters who predict a record number of visitors spending, on average, some $5,000 each. On the other side are economists who say Super Bowl visitors are merely replacing people who would have been here if not for today’s game. It’s an old debate, but one that is more salient in a tourist-driven economy like the one that powers Las Vegas. To those who followed my journey this week: It’s been a pleasure. Enjoy the game.
— Dan Kaplan [[link removed]]
Does the Vegas Super Bowl Make Economic Sense? Depends Where You Get Your Figures
Kirby Lee-USA TODAY Sports
Does today’s Super Bowl, and the festive week that preceded it, make economic sense for Las Vegas? After all, the hotels in Vegas tend to be fully occupied on the weekend of the last game of the year, anyway—and the game itself will draw gamblers, particularly the so-called whales, out of casinos, not into them. So it will be interesting to see whether the Vegas business world gets on board for another run at hosting the top annual sporting event in the U.S.
Boosters of the game foresee a historic economic impact from the week. A projected 150,000 extra visitors will spend an average of four to five times the typical tourist expenditure—that’s what Jeremy Aguero, a principal at the consulting firm Applied Analysis who is on the Las Vegas Super Bowl Host Committee, told reporters last week on a call organized by the U.S. Chamber of Commerce.
“We think about it in gross terms, [where] the total amount of spending activities [are] about $1.1 billion. If we think about it in terms of the net, after we have the displacement effect, it’s something closer to about 800 million dollars in impact.”
That displacement effect is what sports economists contend is the problem with these economic calculations. One can’t just look at the total dollars spent—any estimate has to consider the gap between that figure and what would have been spent anyway. In Vegas, a tourist town, the latter figure is already a big number to begin with.
“We sell out every Super Bowl weekend,” Aguero said. “So there is a displacement effect.” Aguero calculates a small effect by imputing the far heavier spending by Super Bowl visitors.
But it’s unclear from where Aguero and the host committee derived the stat that Super Bowl visitors spend as much as five times the $1,100 average allocated on a normal Vegas trip.
Sports economist J.C. Bradbury believes he has a good idea where that comes from. “A lot of times, the numbers come from [them] just doing a survey,” Bradbury says. “But the person who’s doing the survey is motivated to find the answer. … There is a cottage industry of consultants who are always getting you the biggest number and multiplying it times three or five or something.”
Credit Kirby Lee-USA TODAY Sports
Sports economist Andrew Zimbalist, who in the past has feuded with Bradbury over the subject of economic impact reports, agrees with his rival here. “Most economists who have looked at that usually say, at best: What you should do is move the decimal point to the left one,” he says. “So instead of it being, you know, $300 million, the better estimate would be $30 million.”
The rationale for that multiple is that Super Bowl attendees are wealthy and so they spend more, says Victor Matheson, a sports economist at Holy Cross. The problem with this logic: Sports fans are replacing gamblers, and the usurpers are more apt to spend money in restaurants and retail, lower-margin businesses, than in casinos.
Matheson identifies another issue: yesterday’s Lunar New Year. “Chinese New Year is a gigantic gambling weekend for Vegas normally. In 2007 the NBA had the All-Star Game in Vegas on Chinese New Year weekend,” he says, “and every casino on the Strip said, ‘Never again will we have another sporting event on Chinese New Year, because it was a disaster for our bottom line. We replaced all of these high-roller gamblers with sports fans who are more interested in watching sports than they are in gambling.’
“They blamed an entire quarter of bad results on a sporting event [coming to town during] Chinese New Year. And here we are, 15 years later. Apparently no one remembers that they said, ‘Never again.’”
A counter: Mary Beth Sewald, the president and CEO of the Vegas Chamber of Commerce, told reporters on the Aguero call that the city could not afford the advertising it would take to equal the amount of free publicity it is receiving during the Super Bowl lead-up. And Aguero pointed to the 300 events that occurred in the past week as evidence of economic impact.
Plus, some casinos touted the exposure that the game brings, the stamp of approval, and the projected record gambling handle. “We’ve been waiting for this one for a long time to showcase us as not just an entertainment capital but as a sports capital,” says Dave Horn, the GM of Durango Casino. “I suspect that this handle could be a record breaker.”
The Las Vegas Convention and Visitors Authority offered a preliminary estimate of $500 million in impact, and Brendon Plack, the NFL’s senior vice president of public policy and government affairs, told reporters on the call last week that the final number would be historic. “We’ll know in a few weeks what the tale of the tape says, but we’re expecting a really, really successful weekend.”
What would a record-breaking economic impact look like? Taking these reports with a huge grain of salt, the host committee for last year’s Super Bowl in Phoenix claimed $1.3 billion [[link removed]] in economic activity. That’s far and away the highest one of these economic impact figures for Super Bowls. The Super Bowl before that, in Los Angeles, according to that host committee [[link removed].], produced an impact between $234 million and $477 million.
Aguero noted that inflation will produce higher figures than in the past. That said, in Vegas, which bills itself as the entertainment capital of the country, it’s hard to imagine there is not a great displacement effect in a city that already draws so many high rollers.
“If they were having the Super Bowl in Detroit,” says Zimbalist, “it would have a different effect.”
SPONSORED BY AUTOTRADER
See That Car? Find It on Autotrader
[[link removed]]
Look around. What do you see?
Cars. Lots of them. And guess what? They’re probably on Autotrader [[link removed]].
Big cars, small cars, blue cars, new cars.
Whether you’re into timeless classics or the latest trends (Did somebody say “solar-powered, eco-friendly, vegan leather-wrapped, aromatherapy-scented, disco-ball equipped, self-driving” car?), if you see it on the road, you can likely find it on Autotrader.
New. Used. Electric. And one day… maybe even flying cars. When the dealership is at your fingertips, buying a car becomes a whole lot easier.
Start your search [[link removed]] on Autotrader.
Editors’ Picks Amazon to Exclusively Stream a 2025 NFL Playoff Game [[link removed]]by Alex Schiffer [[link removed]]After passing on a streaming-exclusive game for 2024, Amazon watched Peacock capitalize. The ‘Life-Changing’ Economy of Taylor Swift’s NFL Outfits [[link removed]]by Margaret Fleming [[link removed]]Appearing in Swift’s game-day wardrobe has been “life-changing” for small businesses. The NFL’s Long Road to Las Vegas Harmony [[link removed]]by A.J. Perez [[link removed]]Behind the scenes, a relationship was being forged for decades. Advertise [[link removed]] Awards [[link removed]] Learning [[link removed]] Video [[link removed]] Podcast [[link removed]] Sports Careers [[link removed]] Written by Daniel Kaplan [[link removed]] Edited by Peter Richman [[link removed]], Catherine Chen [[link removed]]
If this email was forwarded to you, you can subscribe here [[link removed]].
Update your preferences [link removed] / Unsubscribe [link removed]
Copyright © 2023 Front Office Sports. All rights reserved.
80 Pine Street Suite 3202 New York, NY 10005
