No images? Click here
January 28, 2024
NEWS DIGEST
by Brandon Waltens
Good morning,
Citizens are celebrating as a court sided with taxpayers on a constitutional amendment proposed in 2021 that would allow counties to issue more taxpayer-backed debt. In its ruling, the Court set a rule ensuring voters are entitled to more information when proposals will impact taxpayers.
Proposition 2, which passed with 63 percent of the vote, would authorize counties to issue bonds (taxpayer-backed debt) to fund infrastructure and transportation projects in underdeveloped, unproductive, or blighted areas and to use increases in property taxes from those areas to pay off the debt. This is known as “tax increment financing” and is a tool currently reserved for cities.
Grassroots groups filed a lawsuit alleging the Proposition 2 ballot language that was put before voters failed to comply with common law requirements and was substantially misleading because it neglected to inform voters the proposal involved debt and property taxes.
Courts have previously ruled that ballot propositions must be described with “such definiteness and certainty that the voters are not misled.” But the proposition 2 language only said it would allow counties to “finance development” and neglected to mention debt or taxes.
In 2011, voters defeated an identical proposition when the state used proper ballot language that discussed the impact the proposal would have on taxpayers.
The lawsuit was brought by Texans Uniting for Reform and Freedom, Grassroots America – We The People, the True Texas Project, and the leaders of the three groups. While a lower court sided with those organizations, the state appealed the decision—leading to a hearing in the Seventh District Court of Appeals in Amarillo earlier this month. The state argued that voters could never challenge language proposed by the legislature, citing the Texas Constitution’s separation of powers provision.
While a decision wasn’t expected for months, on Thursday evening the Court of Appeals issued an opinion siding with taxpayers against the amendment.
The Proposition 2 ballot language approved by voters stated: “A constitutional amendment authorizing a county to finance the development or redevelopment of transportation or infrastructure in unproductive, underdeveloped, or blighted areas in the county.”
In its opinion, the Court noted that the language was facially misleading.
“As can be seen, nothing was said about how the ‘development or redevelopment of transportation or infrastructure’ would be financed or who would fund it. Hidden from view was the ultimate responsibility for payment and its positioning over the voter’s head like the sword of Damocles,” the opinion states.
The opinion went on to quote songs by The Beatles and Johnny Cash:
Whether it be “Taxation without representation” or “Should five percent appear too small, be thankful I don’t take it all” or “There goes the shirt off my back” or “I’m payin’ taxes but what am I buyin’?” each exemplifies the perennial interest of the citizenry in protecting the fruits of their labor from expropriation by the government. No doubt, a component of a constitutional amendment enabling the government to further appropriate money from one’s pocket would be a chief feature of the proposal. It matters not whether the appropriation is certain or a likelihood. The risk of additional loss made possible by adoption of the amendment remains, and it is a risk of historical and prime interest to the voting public.
With the Court of Appeals siding with the lower court, the Attorney General’s office must now decide whether they will once again appeal the
case to the Texas Supreme Court.
Featured
The White House announced Friday that the Biden administration is putting a “temporary pause on pending decisions of Liquified Natural Gas exports.”
The move, said to be made in deference to “the impacts of LNG exports on energy costs, America’s energy security, and our environment,” immediately drew criticism from Texas officials.
Noting that Texas is the third largest exporter of LNG in the world, Texas Land Commissioner Dawn Buckingham posted, “This reckless move is nothing more than retaliation against Texas — for standing up to this administration over the border crisis.”
State
Drew Darby Touts Fake Endorsement from Greg Abbott
After Darby voted with Democrats against a school choice proposal, Abbott endorsed against him.
Texas Will ‘Hold the Line’ On Border Despite Federal Ruling
Texas officials pledge to continue protecting the border after the U.S. Supreme Court ruled federal agents can cut the fencing stopping illegal aliens from entering the state.
George Soros Finances Democrat Political Action Committees
Newly released campaign finance reports show George Soros in the top ten political donors in Texas.
Local
Arlington ISD Trustees Refuse to Answer Questions About District Policies for Gender-Confused Students
David Jarvis has filed a lawsuit against the district and school board for allegedly violating the Texas Open Meetings Act.
Republican-led Fort Worth Celebrates ‘LGBTQ Inclusiveness’ Rating
Fort Worth earned a perfect score for the eighth consecutive year.
Former Austin Police Chief No Longer Returning Following Public Backlash
Art Acevedo’s withdrawal from the role follows fierce public backlash from across the political spectrum.
Federal
Democrats Want Biden to Federalize National Guard Against Texas’ Border Operation
Gov. Abbott has said he will use the state’s constitutional power to push back against the invasion at the border.
‘I’ve Seen Enough’: Cornyn Endorses Trump After New Hampshire Primary
Sen. John Cornyn’s endorsement comes despite a turbulent history between the two.
Texas Officials Slam Biden Administration as Standoff Over Border Security Continues
State officials are blasting the Biden administration for facilitating illegal entry into Texas.
Quoting...
"We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness."
- Declaration of Independence
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Join the conversation with Texas Scorecard on any or all of our social media accounts!
The Texas Scorecard Journalism Fellowship is a comprehensive program designed for conservative Texans under the age of 25 with an interest in public policy, effective civic engagement, political accountability, and Texas history.
