YouTube Quietly Hides Channel Monetization Indicator
On Tuesday, Wired reported that YouTube had removed a piece of code that indicated whether or not a channel was monetized through the YouTube Partner Program, which enables creators to earn a cut of ad revenue generated by their videos. In order to qualify, channels must be “advertiser friendly” and abide by YouTube’s Community Guidelines, which forbid hate speech and “deceptive content with risks of egregious harm.” Former beneficiaries of the YouTube Partner Program include misogynist influencer Andrew Tate and conspiracy theorist Alex Jones, while anti-LGBTQ figures like Matt Walsh continue to profit from their channels. Unfortunately, Community Guidelines don’t actually keep this content off of YouTube. A search for “Andrew Tate” delivers videos that seem to have evaded YouTube’s policies by featuring Tate as a guest. Others are simply reposted from Tate’s Rumble account, or turned into “motivational” montages by fans. YouTube profits from the ads placed on these videos, which is bad enough, but channel monetization creates an incentive for users to repost content from Tate and other banned individuals.
A 2022 report from CfA’s Tech Transparency Project uncovered a large number of YouTube videos uploaded by anti-government militias, which used the platform to promote their activities and attract new recruits. Some of the videos received tens of thousands of views, and depicted training sessions or simulated ambushes. YouTube monetized this content with ads, even though it had removed similar channels run by groups like the Oath Keepers. Even if these channels were not part of the YouTube Partner Program, they provided a dangerous platform for those wishing to spread anti-govenment ideas–especially in the wake of January 6th. Now, thanks to this policy change, it will be impossible for journalists and independent researchers to determine if other YouTube creators are profiting from dangerous or hateful content.
|