View Online [[link removed]] | Subscribe now [[link removed]]Powered byKnow better. Do better.Climate. Change.News from the ground, in a warming world

By Megan Rowling [[link removed]] | Deputy Climate Editor

Pick-your-own transition?

"We will not sign our death certificate," stated the Samoan chair of the Alliance of Small Island States (AOSIS), after the latest version of a potential COP28 climate talks decision was released in Dubai on Monday evening.

The nearly 40 member countries of AOSIS - who warn their very survival is at risk from rising seas fuelled by climate change - said they could not support an agreement "that does not have strong commitments on phasing out fossil fuels". And in its current form, it certainly does not.

After an earlier draft contained no less than four options based on a phase-out of fossil fuels and a fifth involving no mention of it at all, the compromise text last night contained weak wording that offered a "pick-your-own" energy section for countries to triple renewables by 2030 and/or reduce consumption and production of fossil fuels - or simply do nothing. [[link removed]]

Worryingly, the text opens the door for countries to keep on producing oil, coal and gas by using carbon capture and storage [[link removed]] to "abate" their emissions - a technology criticised by many scientists and energy experts who say it's too expensive and that plans to rely heavily on it to meet net-zero goals by 2050 are unrealistic.

Steam rises from the cooling towers of the coal power plant of RWE, one of Europe's biggest electricity and gas companies in Niederaussem, Germany, March 3, 2016. REUTERS/Wolfgang Rattay

The new COP28 text provoked shock and anger, including from European countries like Germany and Spain, whose negotiators said they'd keep talking for as long as it takes to get an ambitious deal with a chance of holding global warming to 1.5C. The United States also said stronger language was needed on fossil fuels.

Last night's ministerial consultations were "very intense" in the words of one talks veteran, and saw more than 70 nations and coalitions making interventions. A new text is expected later today, supposedly the final day of the COP28. It remains to be seen whether a fossil fuel phase-out will make it back onto the table.

So what's the issue, beyond the clear desire of major oil-producing nations like Saudi Arabia, Iraq and Russia to keep pumping the black stuff out of the ground? Finance - or more precisely the lack of it - to help debt-strapped developing countries transition to greener energy.

As former Irish President Mary Robinson told me here in Dubai [[link removed]], any global fossil fuel phase-out will need to be "just" and equitable. That includes support for people whose livelihoods now depend on high-carbon fuels and industries, as well as help to make renewable energy available to all.

"The money is very important, the finance - and I'm worried that we're not seeing enough emphasis on that," she said. [[link removed]]

Adaptation ‘emergency’

Despite putting more than $650 million on the table for the new loss and damage fund at the start of COP28, wealthy countries have been widely criticised for their stinginess when it comes to providing the funding needed for vulnerable countries to adapt to increasingly harsh and erratic weather and climate patterns.

Activists hold placards and shout slogans during a protest, at the United Nations Climate Change Conference COP28 in Dubai, United Arab Emirates, December 6, 2023. REUTERS/Thaier Al-Sudani

Top officials in Dubai told us they're worried that donors could just shuffle the chess pieces, taking money from adaptation [[link removed]] to pay for loss and damage – the unavoidable climate impacts when protecting oneself is no longer an option. [[link removed]]

Meanwhile, the text on how to put into practice a global goal on adaptation - laying out new targets and ways to measure progress in different sectors like water, food and health - does not show how the growing gap in finance for this work will be plugged in the coming years.

With African negotiators saying they face an " adaptation emergency [[link removed]]", the urgency of addressing the injustice of the climate crisis – that those who did the least to cause the problem are suffering the most - is now acute, and a failure to respond could hold back the transition to a net-zero world. [[link removed]]

This comment piece for Context by the prime minister of Bangladesh explains the challenges for her climate-vulnerable country during what she says will be difficult years ahead [[link removed]].

Nature lends a hand

More encouragingly, there has been a coming together of the climate and nature protection agendas at COP28, with the charge led by nature-rich countries like Colombia.

The draft COP28 decision talks about the importance of making high-emitting food systems more climate-resilient and boosting protection for biodiversity and ecosystems, which are vital stores of planet-heating carbon. [[link removed]]

A man carries thatch, which he will use for the roof of his hut, back to his campsite which lies deep in the forest near the city of Mbandaka, Democratic Republic of the Congo, April 3, 2018. REUTERS/Thomas Nicolon

And it's not just forests that play a major role in removing carbon from the atmosphere. Peatlands and mangroves, when in a good state, actually do it better.

Our correspondent Jack Graham went to the Shetland Islands in Scotland to report on a plan to restore its soggy peat bogs [[link removed]]. And, here at COP28, he talked to a conservation warden on Tanzania's Mafia Island about efforts to keep the hidden treasure of its blue lagoon - its mangroves - intact.

Meanwhile, deals are being done thick and fast for rights to develop and sell carbon credits from large tracts of African land, from Nigeria, Rwanda and Ghana to Malawi, Mozambique and Kenya.

But as those countries line up to cash in on the global carbon offset market [[link removed]], concern is growing that the planned multi-million-dollar deals aimed at safeguarding their forests could threaten the land rights and way of life of people who live there, our Africa correspondents report. [[link removed]]

See you next week – by which time we’ll know where the world stands on the future of fossil fuels.

Megan

This week's top picks With Africa's carbon sinks up for grabs, offset debate heats up [[link removed]]

From Kenya to Zimbabwe, swaths of African forest are being locked in carbon offset deals that activists say threaten land rights

Climate tipping points raise game for COP28 fossil fuel phase-out [[link removed]]

Scientists say the risk of 'catastrophic' global shifts is rising, creating new pressure for a fossil fuel phase-out deal at COP28

Climate-hit nations seek COP28 action on 'adaptation emergency' [[link removed]]

As countries haggle over how to put into action a global adaptation goal, calls grow for more cash to boost work on the ground

COP28 'loss and damage' fund could threaten adaptation cash [[link removed]]

Money for climate adaptation could lose out to competition from the 'loss and damage' fund approved at COP28, officials warn

As COP28 targets renewable energy surge, can all nations benefit? [[link removed]]

Momentum has grown behind tripling of renewable energy by 2030, but barriers remain to scale-up in poorer countries

Climate activists say U.N. restricting protest at COP28 [[link removed]]

Climate activists say the U.N. has restricted when and where they can protest at COP28 and banned some phrases about the war in Gaza

How could a COP28 climate deal advance protection of nature? [[link removed]]

Efforts to better link up climate action and nature protection are underway at COP28 in Dubai

No more promises: Young climate activists demand COP28 action [[link removed]]

Young climate change activists at COP28 call on governments to phase out fossil fuels to protect their future

My country needs climate finance now to face difficult years ahead [[link removed]]

Bangladesh needs international support to protect its people from worsening climate change impacts and build out renewable energy

Will COP28 finally set a date to ditch fossil fuels? [[link removed]]

More than half the world backs an end to fossil fuel use – will the Dubai climate talks be the moment that leaders make the historic step?

Read all of our coverage here [[link removed]] Editor's pick Once a dirty fuel, Shetland nurtures peat's climate superpower [[link removed]]

On the Shetland Islands, where sheep graze on peatlands beneath wind turbines, the race to restore a key carbon sink has begun.

[[link removed]]Discover more Nature [[link removed]] Climate Risks [[link removed]] Net Zero [[link removed]] Just Transition [[link removed]] Climate Justice [[link removed]] Green Cities [[link removed]] Thank you for reading!

If you like this newsletter, please forward to a friend or share it on Social Media. [[link removed]]

We value your feedback - let us know what you think [mailto:[email protected]].

This email was sent to you by Thomson Reuters Foundation located at 5 Canada Square, Canary Wharf, London, E14 5AQ - a registered charity in the United Kingdom and the United States.

If you are not the intended recipient, be advised that you have received this email in error and that any use, dissemination, forwarding, printing or copying of this email is strictly prohibited. If you do not wish to receive this type of correspondence in the future, contact us at [[email protected]] so that we can remove you from this list.

Thomson Reuters Foundation terms and conditions and privacy statement can be found online at www.trust.org [[link removed]].

Photos courtesy of Reuters or Thomson Reuters Foundation.

Manage your Subscriptions [[link removed]] | Unsubscribe from all TRF communications [link removed]