[link removed]
FAIR
View article on FAIR's website ([link removed])
Press Relayed Israeli Claims of Secret Hospital Base With Insufficient Skepticism Ari Paul ([link removed])
A cover image of the New York Post (11/16/23 ([link removed]) ) depicted a supposedly shocking find. The headline “Guns Behind the MRI Machine” accompanied a photo of what Israeli troops had allegedly uncovered: Hamas guns at Al Shifa Hospital in Gaza.
On the Post cover were fewer than a dozen AK-47s and matching magazines, as well as a few tactical vests. In its subhead, the Post called this “proof Hamas used hospital as military base in stunning war crime.”
Many other media outlets reported Israel's claims—and accompanying photos and videos the IDF offered as evidence—with little pushback other than Hamas's denials and an acknowledgment that the outlet could not independently verify the claims. "IDF ‘Found Clear Evidence’ of Hamas Operation out of Al-Shifa Hospital, Says Spokesperson," was an NBC News headline (11/15/23 ([link removed]) ); Fox News (11/15/23 ([link removed]) ) had "Watch: Israel Finds Weapons, Military Equipment Used by Hamas in Key Gaza Hospital After Raid, IDF Says."
Israel's assault on Al Shifa hospital provoked widespread international outrage, so a great deal hinged on its claim that the hospital was being used as a military base. But there are many reasons to question this display of weaponry, questions that imply that not only did the Israeli military make a weak case, but that some media outlets and pundits were too quick to take this presentation at face value.
** The laws of war
------------------------------------------------------------
Israeli Defense Force animation depicting what they claimed was underneath the Al-Shifa hospital.
Israeli computer animation (YouTube, 10/27/23 ([link removed]) ) depicting what was claimed to be "the main headquarters for Hamas’ terrorist activity" beneath Al Shifa Hospital.
While civilian infrastructure, and in particular medical infrastructure, are protected ([link removed].) under the laws of war, the Israeli government claimed that the hospital's protection was nullified because Hamas was using it as a military base, using the medical staff and patients as human shields.
The IDF released a 3D animation (YouTube, 10/27/23 ([link removed]) ) depicting Al Shifa as "the main headquarters for Hamas’ terrorist activity," with a warren of underground chambers hiding crates of weapons, missiles, barrels and meeting rooms bedecked with Islamic flags.
The US government supported this line of thinking (ABC News, 11/16/23 ([link removed]) ). The Wall Street Journal editorial board (11/14/23 ([link removed]) ) spelled out the argument:
The law of war in this case is clear: Under the Fourth Geneva Convention, Hamas’s use of Al Shifa for military purposes vitiates the protected status granted to hospitals. Israel is still required to give warning and use means proportionate to the anticipated military advantage, and it has.
But the law of war is not, in fact, clear in the way the Journal claims. “Even if there is a military facility operating under the hospital, this does not allow Israel to bomb the site,” the Israeli human rights group B’Tselem (11/7/23 ([link removed]) ) said in a statement before the hospital raid.
Even if a hospital were used for “acts harmful to the enemy,” that does not give that enemy “the right to bombard it for two days and completely destroy it,” Mathilde Philip-Gay, an expert in international humanitarian law at France's Lyon 3 University, told the Guardian (11/17/23 ([link removed]) ).
“Even if the building loses its special protection, all the people inside retain theirs,” Rutgers Law School international law expert Adil Haque told the Washington Post (11/15/23 ([link removed]) ). “Anything that the attacking force can do to allow the humanitarian functions of that hospital to continue, they’re obligated to do.” The director of the hospital, Mohammad Abu Salmiya, said that 179 patients died while the facility was surrounded by Israeli forces and had to be buried in a mass grave (Al Jazeera, 11/14/23 ([link removed]) ). (Abu Salmiya was later arrested by Israeli forces along with other Palestinian medical personnel—Al Jazeera, 11/11/23 ([link removed]) .)
After the raid, viewing the evidence, Human Rights Watch was not at all persuaded. "Hospitals have special protections under international humanitarian law," said Human Rights Watch UN director Louis Charbonneau (Reuters, 11/16/23 ([link removed]) ):
Doctors, nurses, ambulances and other hospital staff must be permitted to do their work and patients must be protected. Hospitals only lose those protections if it can be shown that harmful acts have been carried out from the premises. The Israeli government hasn’t provided any evidence of that.
"The IDF says attacks are justified because Hamas fighters use the hospital as a military command center," Amnesty International Australia (11/27/23 ([link removed]) ) noted. "But so far, they’ve failed to produce any credible evidence to substantiate this claim."
** Shrugging off skepticism
------------------------------------------------------------
Washington Post: Evidence confirms Israel’s al-Shifa claims, so critics move the goal posts
The Washington Post's Jennifer Rubin (11/20/23 ([link removed]) ) dismissed demands that Israel produce evidence of the "command-and-control center" it said justified the assault on the Al Shifa hospital.
Washington Post columnist Jennifer Rubin (11/20/23 ([link removed]) ) shrugged off skepticism of the evidence presented about the hospital, scorning critics who demanded proof that the hospital was a "command center"—which she dismissed as "a generic term without definition and without legal significance.” Rubin insisted: “It was used as a military facility. Period.”
AP (11/23/23 ([link removed]) ), however, pointed out that it was the Israeli military, not the military’s critics, who had promised evidence that the hospital served as "an elaborate Hamas command-and-control center under the territory’s largest healthcare facility." After the hospital's capture, former Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert told Euronews (11/17/23 ([link removed]) ) that Al Shifa was not Hamas's headquarters after all: "Khan Younis, which is in the southern part of Gaza Strip, is the real headquarters of Hamas," he said.
Another Post columnist, Kathleen Parker (11/17/23 ([link removed]) ), admitted that details of the military’s find were scarce and that perhaps media shouldn’t jump to conclusions, but then immediately said the photographic release “seems” to vindicate Israel:
As media teams try to understand what’s happening there, details are few, leaving much room for speculation and/or affirmation of one’s preferred narrative.
Even so, the video, which has been replayed by dozens of news outlets, seems to confirm what Israel has long claimed that Hamas uses innocent Palestinians as barricades by installing their headquarters and arsenals beneath schools, hospitals and other public institutions in a vast complex of subterranean tunnels.
About that supposed headquarters beneath the hospital: While Israel showed off images of a "tunnel" under the hospital, Newsweek (11/15/23 ([link removed]) ) pointed out that it's long been known that the facility had an extensive sub-basement—because it was built by Israel in 1983.
** Catastrophe for hospitals
------------------------------------------------------------
Middle East Eye: Israeli forces storm al-Shifa hospital where thousands seek refuge
Middle East Eye (11/15/23 ([link removed]) ): "While Israel says its military has been conducting a 'precise and targeted operation' at Al Shifa, Palestinians at the hospital say civilians trying to flee have been fired upon."
Israel’s assault on Gaza has generally been a catastrophe for Gaza hospitals (UN News, 11/13/23 ([link removed]) ; BBC, 11/13/23 ([link removed]) ), and there has been considerable damage to Gaza hospitals in previous Israeli assaults (Guardian, 3/24/09 ([link removed]) ; Newsweek, 7/30/14 ([link removed]) ; Guardian, 5/16/21 ([link removed]) ).
And the Israeli operation at the hospital was certainly stunning. The Middle East Eye (11/15/23 ([link removed]) ) reported:
Troops broke through the northern walls of the complex, instead of entering via the main gate to the east, at around 2 am local time on Wednesday, according to local sources and health officials.
They went building to building inside the large facility, removing doctors, patients and displaced people to the courtyards before interrogating them, Middle East Eye has learned.
Some people were stripped naked, blindfolded and detained, according to doctors who spoke to Al Jazeera Arabic, one of the few international channels with access to sources within the hospital.
This isn’t to say media outlets shouldn’t scrutinize what Hamas fighters do in civilian areas, but there is a lack of skepticism in media—especially for television news and tabloids that depend on gripping photography—when it comes to Israel’s presentation of its findings in Gaza that lead to more murkiness.
------------------------------------------------------------
Research assistance: Pai Liu, Keating Zelenke
Read more ([link removed])
Share this post: <a rel="nofollow" target="_blank" href="[link removed]" title="Twitter"><img border="0" height="15" width="15" src="[link removed]" title="Twitter" alt="Twitter" class="mc-share"></a>
<a rel="nofollow" target="_blank" href="[link removed]" title="Facebook"><img border="0" height="15" width="15" src="[link removed]" title="Facebook" alt="Facebook" class="mc-share"></a>
<a rel="nofollow" target="_blank" href="[link removed]" title="Pinterest"><img border="0" height="15" width="15" src="[link removed]" title="Pinterest" alt="Pinterest" class="mc-share"></a>
<a rel="nofollow" target="_blank" href="[link removed]" title="LinkedIn"><img border="0" height="15" width="15" src="[link removed]" title="LinkedIn" alt="LinkedIn" class="mc-share"></a>
<a rel="nofollow" target="_blank" href="[link removed]" title="Google Plus"><img border="0" height="15" width="15" src="[link removed]" title="Google Plus" alt="Google Plus" class="mc-share"></a>
<a rel="nofollow" target="_blank" href="[link removed]" title="Instapaper"><img border="0" height="15" width="15" src="[link removed]" title="Instapaper" alt="Instapaper" class="mc-share"></a>
© 2021 Fairness & Accuracy in Reporting. All rights reserved.
You are receiving this email because you signed up for email alerts from
Fairness & Accuracy in Reporting
Our mailing address is:
FAIRNESS & ACCURACY IN REPORTING
124 W. 30th Street, Suite 201
New York, NY 10001
FAIR's Website ([link removed])
FAIR counts on your support to do this work — please donate today ([link removed]) .
Follow us on Twitter ([link removed]) | Friend us on Facebook ([link removed])
change your preferences ([link removed])
Email Marketing Powered by Mailchimp
[link removed]
unsubscribe ([link removed]) .