Can any of the Republican presidential contenders surpass Trump? | Read Intercollegiate Review every Thursday for the best of intellectual conservative thought.
Email not displaying correctly?
View it in your browser.


 
CATEGORY: POLITICS (10 MIN)

A reducing pot

Another month into the presidential campaign season brings yet another Republican primary debate. The field continued to shrink, now to only five candidates on stage. Former Vice President Mike Pence dropped out of the race and North Dakota Governor Doug Burgum failed to qualify for the most recent clash in Miami.

The New York Times has been recapping each debate through the eyes of its Opinion writers. In this edition, the commentators included Daniel McCarthy, ISI’s Vice President for the Collegiate Network and editor-in-chief of Modern Age, and Ross Douthat, longtime NYT columnist and ISI alumnus.

Douthat and McCarthy diverged from the other critics in reviewing Nikki Haley’s performance. While others placed her at a 7 or higher, Douthat put her at a 5 out of 10 (still his highest rating of the debate). He thought Haley was rhetorically and stylistically effective but couldn’t show how she’d break into more conservative circles. McCarthy rated her a 3, criticizing her neoconservative foreign policy positions.

Haley’s erstwhile rival, Vivek Ramaswamy, received extremely low marks from most of the NYT staff. Douthat gave him a 3, but said that beneath his frustrating bluster, Ramaswamy was making interesting points. McCarthy placed Ramaswamy at an 8, expressing his thankfulness that someone was willing to play the villain.

For the rest of the ratings, read the full article with our NYT guest link right here.


Weekly Poll

RESULTS: 11/9/23

Last week, we asked: Do you think some of the bureaucrats in Washington, D.C., undermined Trump's effectiveness while he was in office? Here are the results:

[A] Yes - 77.1%
[B] No - 17.7%
[C] Unsure - 5.2%

After the third debate, who is your favorite Republican presidential candidate?

[A] Donald Trump
[B] Nikki Haley
[C] Ron DeSantis
[D] Chris Christie
[E] Tim Scott
[F] Vivek Ramaswamy
[G] Unsure


CATEGORY: POLITICS (5 MIN)

Matter of life and death

On Election Day this month, Ohio passed a state constitutional amendment which protected the desires of abortionists and abandoned the rights of unborn children. Conservatives reacted with a cry of despair over the measure, with many questioning the best way to approach the life issue in the wake of many pro-abortion state victories after Dobbs.

For The American Conservative, Collegiate Network alumna Carmel Richardson urges conservatives not to abandon the pro-life fight. Instead, she argues for a shift in strategy.

Richardson notes that pro-abortion advocates tend to posture themselves as having the moral high ground, using appeals to women’s “health” and “reproductive freedom.” In response, Richardson pushes for conservatives to reclaim the moral language of the pro-life position. Rather than equivocating and finding exceptions, which Richardson sees as the prevailing post-Dobbs strategy, she believes pro-lifers should return to reminding voters that life begins at conception. She says everything flows from this first principle.

Richardson perceives equivocation on abortion as signaling weakness and inconsistency to voters—two indicators of a losing argument. And until that equivocation changes, she contends, the pro-life movement will keep losing.

Read Richardson’s entire argument here.​​​

CATEGORY: PODCAST EPISODE

Why You Should Care About Art | Jane Scharl

In this episode, ISI’s own Jane Scharl joins the podcast to talk about:

  • her work as a professional poet and playwright
  • why everyone needs to appreciate the fine arts to be fully human, and how to get started for beginners
  • why beauty changes and saves the world by changing and saving souls, and how to become a patron of artists to produce more beautiful things

Texts Mentioned:

​​​​​​​

Christmas Open House 

​​​December 12th, 2023

Join ISI this Christmas and Holiday season at our Christmas Open House in our newly dedicated Linda L. Bean Conference Center.

This festive evening will feature local award-winning historian W. Barksdale Maynard from the University of Delaware. He will speak on his book The Brandywine: An Intimate Portrait. From the Battle of the Brandywine in 1777—a character-forming crucible of war for George Washington—to the rise of the Brandywine School of Art, our region has made rich contributions to American liberty, arts, and culture.

Don't miss an open bar reception, lecture, and Q&A as we celebrate the Brandywine Valley’s contributions to the American tradition!

Join us in Wilmington, DE >>>


Because our student editors and writers are bravely bringing conservative ideas to their campuses, we’re highlighting their efforts here.
Bishop, Students Decry University-Sanctioned Drag Show via The Irish Rover
“The Film, Television, and Theatre (FTT) one-credit course, ‘What a Drag: Drag on Screen—Variations and Meanings,’ held a drag performance and symposium in the Debartolo Performing Arts Center (DPAC) on Friday, November 3, as originally reported by the Rover. Hundreds of protesters and counter-protesters assembled outside of DPAC during the show to express their opinions on the controversial event.”

Michael Knowles Speaks at Cornell via Cornell Review
“On November 6, Michael Knowles, a Daily Wire show host and conservative commentator lectured on ‘The Mirage of Free Speech’ before a crowd of 260... Knowles was introduced by Rodge Reschini, President of the Cornell Republicans, who emphasized the importance of being open to other viewpoints.”

Palestine Protesters Block Entry to Pomona College Building via The Claremont Independent
“On Thursday, November 9th, students from across the Claremont Colleges protested at Pomona College, demanding divestment from Israel. At 7:30 A.M., students dressed in black garb and face masks blocked off entrances to Alexander Hall, an administrative building, as well as the attached Career Development Office.”

Shackled Stanford’s Regulatory Demise via The Stanford Review
“Stanford is indeed beautiful, but the veneer of blissful harmony is underlied by a system of excessive safety measures—bordering on theater—and synthetic attempts at community-building that hamper students’ ability to have rich social lives and the agency to fully explore and enjoy campus.”

Princeton SJP Hosts “Walkout for Palestine,” Journalists Face Harassment via The Princeton Tory
“On Thursday, November 9, at 12:00 p.m., Princeton’s chapter of Students for Justice in Palestine (SJP) hosted a ‘Walkout for Palestine’ on Princeton’s campus. The protest was coordinated as part of a nationwide campus walkout, with demonstrations also occurring at Columbia University, the University of Michigan, and elsewhere. At the event, Tory reporters were obstructed from filming by protestors as the crowd repeated calls such as ‘globalize the Intifada.’”

The College Fix recently published an article about a reporter for The Princeton Tory’s experience being pushed and harassed at a pro-Palestinian rally.
​​​​​​​​​​​​

CATEGORY: CULTURE (8 MIN)

Elves and hobbits

The abortion issue and other cultural divides in our nation have split today’s Americans, but not just along ideological lines. Within each camp, individuals must decide how much they wish to involve themselves in these battles. And many conservatives can be internally torn between moral duties to family, to nation, and to God.

For this week’s Intercollegiate Review archive, Gene Callahan dives into this issue. Callahan analyzes the recent work of thinker Curtis Yarvin, who claimed to divide Americans into “hobbits” and “elves.”

American hobbits, in Yarvin’s world, are those who care mainly about their own private lives and tend to avoid helping shape the political regime. Callahan says that breaking these so-called hobbits out of their daily patterns is a difficult task. So how should those who wish to shape society proceed? Callahan believes Yarvin is promoting a “neutral regime” (as to tradition) as an answer.

Callahan also responds to critics of Yarvin, especially on the point that Yarvin called Dobbs a loss for the pro-life movement. Callahan doesn’t agree with Yarvin that Dobbs is a loss, but he takes Yarvin’s important pragmatic point.

“It is prudential . . . to consider the long-term impact of some governmental action, rather than merely looking at whether it appears to be a victory for one’s side,” Callahan writes.

Read Callahan’s thought-provoking piece right here.


Thought of the Day:
 
“Any country that accepts abortion is the poorest of the poor.”
 
- St. Teresa of Calcutta
​​​​​

Join ISI’s new Alumni Giving Club

It’s never been easier for you to support our mission—and stay part of our community—with ISI’s new Alumni Giving Club! 

For just $19.53 a month, you can join the fight and “pay it forward” by educating the next generation for ordered liberty. 

Join the Club

 

Follow on Twitter   Friend on Facebook   Forward to Friend 
Copyright © 2023, All rights reserved.

Our mailing address is:

Intercollegiate Studies Institute
3901 Centerville Road
Wilmington, DE 19807
unsubscribe from all emails   update subscription preferences