** Gas utilities evaded federal stove regulations with Big Tobacco tactics ([link removed])
------------------------------------------------------------
By Charlie Spatz on Oct 23, 2023 05:13 pm
Gas utilities fended off federal regulations of gas stoves by deploying the same tactics as the tobacco industry to undermine public health research, according to a new report ([link removed]) published by the Climate Investigations Center.

NPR published a story ([link removed]) featuring the report, including exclusive interviews with some of the first scientists to identify the health risks of gas stove emissions as early as the 1970s. A Morning Edition segment aired on Monday, October 24th.

Dr. Carl Shy, one of the NPR interviewees, published ([link removed]) epidemiological research in 1970 which found that young children were more susceptible to respiratory ailments if they lived in a house with gas stoves.

In response, the American Gas Association (AGA) hired Battelle Laboratories, which was simultaneously producing favorable research for Philip Morris ([link removed]) and other tobacco industry clients. Battelle’s research ([link removed]) found “no significant difference in reported respiratory illness between the members of households cooking with gas and those cooking with electricity.” Tobacco industry records show Batelle reliably provided research “consistent with the Sponsor’s interests and wishes.” ([link removed])

In many instances, Battelle, AGA, or other gas industry organizations were not disclosed as funders of the research that the industry then used to downplay gas stove risks and calls for indoor air pollution regulation, according to the CIC report.

Industry-funded epidemiological studies finding no or minimal health risks from gas stoves grew into the 1980s as federal regulators contemplated setting nitrogen dioxide standards. By the time the Environmental Protection Agency performed a literature review ([link removed]) for the National Ambient Air Quality Standards for Nitrogen Dioxide in 1982 and 1985, over half of the studies examined were industry-funded. All of the non-industry-funded studies found respiratory risks, except for a single outlier study that only looked at adults.

To this day, no U.S. federal indoor air pollution standards are in place ([link removed]) .

Epidemiological studies came at an inconvenient time in the 1970s and the 2020s

The epidemiological research in the 1970s came at an inconvenient time for gas utilities as several other crises threatened the industry’s plans for growth.

In 1969, the gas industry launched a marketing campaign called “Operation Attack” ([link removed]) to greatly expand the number of gas stoves in U.S. homes. The nationwide public relations campaign to boost gas range sales involved national television commercials, consumer and trade magazine advertisements, along with sales promotions and consultation with appliance retailers, the CIC report documented. It was described as “the most ambitious advertising and merchandising program ever undertaken by the gas industry.” As is still the case today, the gas stove has long acted as a gateway appliance ([link removed]) to convince homeowners to connect their homes to the gas distribution grid.

Dr. Shy’s research, which was featured in the New York Times and escalated calls for legislative action, risked putting a damper on AGA’s growth strategy.

In 1972, Richard Darrow, an executive at the prominent PR firm Hill & Knowlton, addressed gas industry executives at an annual public relations workshop hosted by AGA and the Interstate National Gas Association of America (INGAA). Darrow recommended that the industry “mount the massive, consistent, long-range public relations programs.” He said they needed to get ahead of bad news “before the critics take the floor.”

Hill & Knowlton, and Darrow in particular, were the masterminds behind the tobacco industry’s public relations strategy.

Gas utilities find themselves in a similar position today, as new public health risks re-emerged ([link removed]) and dominated news cycles in 2023. Peer-reviewed research ([link removed]) found “12.7 percent of current childhood asthma in the United States can be linked to gas stove use” and a study ([link removed]) from Stanford University researchers and PSE Health Energy found Benzene generated from gas stoves can reach levels comparable to second-hand tobacco smoke.

More existentially for gas utilities, many states, including most recently New York ([link removed]) , have enacted policies restricting gas hook-ups in new construction, motivated by efforts to reduce the greenhouse gas pollution that causes climate change. Over 100 cities ([link removed]) across the country have also passed ordinances to encourage electrification and restrict gas in new construction.

Price spikes in the 1970s and 2020s created further headaches for the gas industry

The crisis facing the gas industry over epidemiological research was compounded further by energy commodities spiking in the 1970s as geopolitical conflicts broke out across the globe.

Skyrocketing oil and gas prices due to geopolitical conflicts of the Cold War meant gas utilities faced skepticism from regulators, politicians, and consumers over the expansion of the gas distribution system, which was still in its infancy in much of the United States.

Methane gas prices increased again in 2022, caused by Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and by the linking of US gas prices with global markets due to increased US LNG exports. The price spikes provided further incentives for policymakers to favor more efficient heat pumps in new construction and retrofits. The Biden Administration directed billions ([link removed]) in federal funds to support heat pump installations and Colorado ([link removed]) , which was hit especially hard by methane price increases, added its own incentives.

AGA’s responses to modern threats echo tobacco strategy

The American Gas Association responded to the threats ([link removed]) by supporting its members’ efforts to pass “preemption legislation,” which prohibits municipalities from restricting gas in construction. It mimics the tobacco industry’s efforts ([link removed]) to pass similar legislation that prevented municipalities from banning indoor smoking at public venues, such as restaurants.

The gas industry is also suspected of funding ([link removed]) a prominent federal lawsuit by the California Restaurant Association (CRA), which challenged Berkeley, California’s efforts to curtail gas use in new construction. The law firm representing CRA, Reichman Jorgensen, has received millions from Southern California Gas Company (SoCalgas), one of the largest gas utilities in the United States, according to an investigation by The Sacramento Bee. SoCalGas disputes its payments to Reichman funded the Berkeley lawsuit.

Funding hospitality organizations, particularly the restaurant industry, was a strategy that Philip Morris employed to keep an arm’s length distance from their fight against “smoke free environments,” according to tobacco industry historians and experts ([link removed]) .

In early 2022, a New York Times investigation highlighted an incident in which a toxicologist from Gradient Corporation downplayed the risks of gas stoves in oral testimony to the Multnomah County Board of Supervisors, without disclosing her organization’s financial ties to AGA. Like Battelle in the 1970s, Gradient Corporation has provided favorable studies to the tobacco industry since the mid-1980s. AGA has also sent letters written by Gradient ([link removed]) to the American Medical Association (AMA) in an attempt to change the organization’s warnings to the medical community about health risks from gas stoves. AMA has not changed that position.

AGA also has promoted a 2013 report based on the International Study of Asthma and Allergies in Childhood (ISAAC) that used survey data to conclude that no association existed between gas cooking and lifetime asthma or current asthma, compared to children who lived in households with electric stoves. That study was based on a global survey and not on measured concentrations of NO2 in the home. A co-author of the study said that AGA has misused the study. “That’s not a good use of our study,” environmental epidemiology professor Bert Brunekreef told ([link removed]) E&E News.

Brunekreef conducted ([link removed]) a separate analysis in 2013, published in the International Journal of Epidemiology, which found that in children, gas cooking increased the risk of asthma. Despite the criticism, AGA used that study ([link removed]) in social media advertisements earlier this year when the Consumer Product Safety Commission opened a docket in March to review both the information on the hazards associated with gas ranges and proposed solutions.

AGA under pressure as utilities face pressure to jump ship and lawmakers band recovery dues

Eversource, the largest owner of utilities in New England, left the American Gas Association over differences in climate policy earlier this year, according to WBUR ([link removed]) . Eversource has sought to distance itself ([link removed]) in recent years from AGA’s climate policies, including AGA’s advocacy against a recent Department of Energy water heating efficiency rule ([link removed]) . Eversource also left the Consortium to Combat Electrification, housed in the AGA-affiliated Energy Solutions Center, after a story about its membership was published in the E&E News ([link removed]) .

Calls for more utilities to follow Eversource’s lead have emerged across the United States. Consumer and climate organizations have called on Pacific Gas and Electric and Puget Sound Energy to leave AGA.

Four states, Connecticut ([link removed]) , Colorado ([link removed]) , Maine ([link removed]) , and New York ([link removed]) , have recently passed legislation prohibiting utilities from charging ratepayers for their dues to trade associations, including AGA. Ohio lawmakers have introduced ([link removed]) similar legislation, and the Louisiana Public Service Commission opened a docket to explore utilities’ political and advocacy spending that sets the stage for implementing similar restrictions. U.S. Representative Kathy Castor also introduced legislation ([link removed]) that directs the Federal Energy Regulatory
Commission to prohibit utilities from recovering political expenses, including trade association dues, from ratepayers through wholesale transmission rates, which are separate from the rates regulated by state public utility commissions.

The post Gas utilities evaded federal stove regulations with Big Tobacco tactics ([link removed]) appeared first on Energy and Policy Institute ([link removed]) .
Read in browser » ([link removed])
[link removed] [link removed]




** Recent Articles:
------------------------------------------------------------
** Fossil fuel money lurks behind anti-offshore wind power political ads in New Jersey  ([link removed])
** Michigan legislators took $176K from DTE since pledging new era of utility accountability after outage backlash ([link removed])
** Alabama Commission President Misleads Legislative Review Committee about Alabama Power’s High Rate of Profit ([link removed])
** Florida Supreme Court orders Florida Public Service Commission to do its job ([link removed])
** Maryland utilities lobbying against adoption of local electrification policies ([link removed]

============================================================
** Facebook ([link removed])
** Twitter ([link removed])
** Website ([link removed])
Copyright © 2023 Energy and Policy Institute, All rights reserved.
You are receiving this email because you opted in at our website via our Contact Us page.

Our mailing address is:
Energy and Policy Institute
P.O. Box 170399
San Francisco, CA 94117
USA
Want to change how you receive these emails?
You can ** update your preferences ([link removed])
or ** unsubscribe from this list ([link removed])
.
Email Marketing Powered by Mailchimp
[link removed]