He had the nerve to write about a conversation two players had in front of the media, but before media availability officially started. Email not displaying correctly?
View it in your browser ([link removed]) .
[link removed]
[link removed]


** OPINION
------------------------------------------------------------


** Shameful: USC football temporarily bans reporter from covering the team
------------------------------------------------------------
University of Southern California football coach Lincoln Riley, shown here before a game last month. (AP Photo/Jae C. Hong)

Are there any people on the planet who are bigger control freaks than college football coaches?

The latest example of power run amok comes from the University of Southern California, where head football coach Lincoln Riley (along with the university’s director of football communications) has banned a reporter who covers the team for two weeks over … well, over pretty flimsy excuses.

Actually, they’re banning him because they’re thin-skinned and petty. But let’s get to the official reason.

USC is claiming that Luca Evans, who covers the Trojans for The Orange County Register and the Southern California News Group, violated the program’s media policies. USC and Riley apparently were irked that in the lead of one story ([link removed]) , Evans wrote about two players talking to each other about being nervous to speak to reporters. The conversation was held in front of the media, but before the official media availability started. And that, USC claimed, was a violation of policy.

The anecdote was pretty innocent stuff, it didn’t reveal anything embarrassing or give away football secrets. If anything, it showed the players in an endearing way. In fact, Evans reached out to the father of one of the players, and the dad thought the conversation was funny and accurate.

In a staff-written report ([link removed]) , the Register wrote, “(Director of football communications Katie) Ryan had earlier in the season brought up concerns to SCNG editors about Evans, who is on his first season on the USC beat. They included asking a question when a press conference had been concluded and talking to players and coaches in areas on campus that weren’t designated as media availabilities.”

Oh my, the nerve of Evans for doing his, you know, job. And to think that USC actually complained about something that minor, for goodness’ sake.

The Southern California News Group believes the suspension is an overreaction and sent a letter this week asking Riley, USC athletic director Jennifer Cohen and USC president Carol Folt to reconsider. Cohen responded, in part, by writing, “As you know, our media policies exist to protect our student-athletes and promote a culture of trust that is critical to building successful programs. After careful consideration and in alignment with the sentiment above, USC supports the football program’s decision regarding Luca’s two-week suspension. We recognize this may be disappointing, but we hope you can understand the need to enforce our media policies as we strive to create a positive and comfortable environment for our players and coaches.”

There also was a report that Ryan was annoyed that Evans called the school president by her first name.

Seriously?!

The pushback from the media around the country was swift.

USA Today For The Win’s Blake Schuster wrote ([link removed]) , “Lincoln Riley and USC have spent the first three weeks of the season proving how dominant they are on the field and the past few days proving how dumb and petty they are off of it.”

Jenni Carlson, the former Oklahoman columnist now with the new startup SelloutCrowd.com, covered Riley when he was the coach at Oklahoma University. She said ([link removed]) , “I wish I could say I’m surprised Lincoln put a two-week ban on a reporter, but that tracks with what we saw during his time in Norman. He never did anything that harsh, though OU did cancel a day of media availability in 2021 after a couple of student reporters watched practice from the upper reaches of the journalism building across the street. But there was always a sense that Lincoln had a very tight grip on media access. Who was allowed to do interviews. Who wasn’t. He absolutely wanted to control the narrative, and really, that’s what he wasn’t able to do with the OC Register reporter. And Riley is throwing around his weight trying to keep anyone else from doing something like this in the future.”

Like I said: College football coaches — at least most that I’ve come across — are control freaks.

Brady McCollough, who covers college sports for the Los Angeles Times and has spent a lot of time around the USC program, tweeted ([link removed]) , “USC has suspended a reporter from the beat for two weeks. Are you freaking kidding me? So *this* is the Lincoln Riley Oklahoma media were warning us about.”

Of course, all this ire from Riley, Ryan and USC is under the guise of “protecting the players.” But Front Office Sports’ Amanda Christovich tweeted ([link removed]) , “This is not about ‘protecting players’ as Lincoln Riley contends — it’s about controlling them. Reporters have so little access to players as it is. We can’t reach out one-on-one. We’re threatened with being blacklisted if we do so. Let the kids talk. If a player is talking w/in earshot of a journalist, they know better than to let us hear them. They’re not toddlers.”

Chrsitovich added that USC is “ a joke” for this maneuver.

Veteran sportswriter Jeff Pearlman tweeted ([link removed]) , “I know (Ryan) is just taking orders from yet another DI football coach who thinks he's God, but this is absolute (expletive) amateur hour from @USC. Beyond shameful. Would be nice to have media relations people stand up for the media. Alas …”

Jim Alexander — a columnist for The Press-Enterprise, part of the Southern California News Group — wrote ([link removed]) , “… maybe he’s just resorting to the traditional college football coach’s playbook: Assert control, and steer the coverage of your team into friendly territory, by bullying the new guy on the beat and intimidating the others.”

Alexander added, “If you’re reading this publication, you are benefitting from independent reporting, again without fear or favor. And so we go back to the very beginning: The news source does not have the right to dictate who does — or doesn’t — cover the beat.”

Alexander also wrote, “And by the way, if Riley thinks I deserve a ‘suspension’ after this, he shouldn’t waste his breath. I’m ‘suspending’ USC football from this column for a while.”

And what did Evans, the reporter who was suspended, have to say? He showed professionalism by tweeting ([link removed]) : “As the Orange County Register has reported, USC has suspended my access for two weeks. I will continue covering the program as best I possibly can, and have some exciting stories in the works. I appreciate the support of members of the media, and am determined to continue to tell engaging stories that capture these athletes as people.”

Bottom line: This is an embarrassing look from a university and college football coach who wants to control every aspect of their program — even the parts that don’t come under their authority.

Shameful and disturbing. But not at all surprising.

A NOTE FROM POYNTER
[link removed]


** Celebrate journalism with Anderson Cooper
------------------------------------------------------------

Anderson Cooper will accept the Poynter Medal for Lifetime Achievement in Journalism at the Poynter Institute's annual Bowtie Ball on Saturday, Nov. 18, at the JW Marriott Tampa Water Street in Tampa, Florida.

Join us for an elegant celebration of journalism and democracy and get the scoop behind Cooper's career-defining coverage during an exclusive on-stage interview. Bow ties and dancing shoes are encouraged!

Learn more and get tickets ► ([link removed])


** Evan Gershkovich: A worrisome waiting game
------------------------------------------------------------
Wall Street Journal reporter Evan Gershkovich stands in a glass cage in a courtroom at the Moscow City Court in Russia this week. (AP Photo/Dmitry Serebryakov)

The White House said it continues to work to free Wall Street Journal reporter Evan Gershkovich, who has been detained in Russia since March. But they also admit that freeing him remains difficult.

Gershkovich was detained on charges of espionage. The White House and The Wall Street Journal have vehemently denied Gershkovich is a spy and the White House considers him “wrongfully detained.”

John Kirby, the National Security Council’s coordinator for strategic communications, told MSNBC on Wednesday, “I can tell you there’s not a single day since Evan has been incarcerated that we haven’t worked on that case.”

The U.S. is also trying to free businessman Paul Whelan, who was sentenced to 16 years in prison on an espionage charge in 2020.

Kirby said, “Because it’s espionage, the Russians sort of treat them differently. So it’s going to be, you know, could be potentially tough to continue to work to get them back.”

The U.S. is said to be in “very active” discussions with Russia about releasing Gershkovich and Whelan.


** Lester Holt’s thoughts on diversity and the ‘higher calling’ of journalism
------------------------------------------------------------
“NBC Nightly News” anchor Lester Holt, shown here in 2019. (AP Photo/Richard Drew)

“NBC Nightly News” anchor Lester Holt was the headliner at The National Association for Multi-Ethnicity in Communications’s 37th annual conference this week in New York City. In a conversation with “NBC News Daily” anchor Morgan Radford, Holt talked about the importance of diversity within the newsroom and other journalism topics, including why he believes being a reporter is a “high calling.”

About diversity in the newsroom, Holt said, “It’s so vitally important to have people in the newsroom who have different experiences in life. Certainly within the organization, as well as the industry as a whole, I think there is a recognition that people want to turn on the TV and see people that kind of look like them, or maybe have had experiences kind of like them. I think from a storytelling purpose, which is what we do every night — we're storytellers — it's so vitally important to have people in the newsroom who have different experiences in life.”

About why being a reporter is a “high calling,” Holt said, “One of the other pieces of advice I got from a mentor years ago, who has now passed on, but he said, being a reporter is the highest calling of our business and I get a lot of attention being the anchor of ‘NBC Nightly News.’ To me, the joy in this job is being out and covering stories. Sitting at that wonderful plexiglass desk every night with all the monitors and stuff, it's prestigious. It's an important job. But I always look back, I think, the most thrilling, interesting, fascinating moments of my career have not been in studio, they've been outside the studio. Being a reporter is the highest calling, not being the anchor, but being a reporter. And so I take that to heart every day and that's kind of the principle, I think, most of us stand on.”


** New York Times Sports becomes Sports from The Athletic
------------------------------------------------------------

As I wrote about earlier this week ([link removed]) , The New York Times has officially closed its sports department. So now, if you go to the Times website and click on the “sports” label at the top of the homepage, you are directed to a sports page that says:

Sports from The Athletic.

Then it lists one main story with a big photo. And that is surrounded by eight stories with smaller photos.

Scroll down and it says “New York Times Sports.” Under that heading are five stories written by what are now former Times sportswriters. You would assume that, eventually, that “New York Times Sports” header (and stories written by former Times sportswriters) will disappear when those stories are no longer timely or relevant.


** Show the replay, ABC
------------------------------------------------------------

In Wednesday’s newsletter ([link removed]) , I wrote about how ABC should have shown a replay of the gruesome knee injury suffered by Cleveland Browns running back Nick Chubb on “Monday Night Football.” ABC chose not to show it. My argument was fans should see how brutal the sport can be and not showing the replay is sanitizing the dangers of the game.

Popular radio host Dan Patrick, whose show is simulcast on Peacock, also thought the replay should have been shown.

Patrick said on his show ([link removed]) that not showing Chubb’s injury did the audience a disservice. He said, “You have to show it again to at least put it in context of what happened there. They decided they weren’t going to do it. I would’ve done it. I would’ve done it once, because you’re carrying the game. You owe it to the audience. You could do a disclaimer. I might be in the minority here, but if I was running the show I would say, ‘Joe, give them a disclaimer, we’re gonna show this. Just let them know that this is a gruesome injury.’ You show it once.”

ABC/ESPN is defending its decision to not show it. An ESPN spokesperson told The Athletic’s Richard Deitsch ([link removed]) , “We viewed the replays in our production truck immediately after the play and decided to use discretion out of respect to the viewers and Nick Chubb.”


** Media tidbits
------------------------------------------------------------
* For Nieman Lab, Kelly Bjorklund and Simon J. Smith with “Evidence suggests Russia has been deliberately targeting journalists in Ukraine — a war crime.” ([link removed])
* ABC News announces the new landing spot for the data-driven 538. Here’s more ([link removed]) .
* Vanity Fair’s Joe Pompeo talks to Michael Wolff about Wolff’s new book on Fox News’ big boss Rupert Murdoch: “Murdoch Chronicler Michael Wolff Foresees the Fall of Fox News: ‘It Will Cease to Exist in Its Present Form.’” ([link removed])
* Here is a list of recent corrections from The Wall Street Journal ([link removed]) . What makes that notable: It includes a correction from a story written in 1963!


** Hot type
------------------------------------------------------------

If you only read one thing today, read this touching and beautifully done story in the Deseret News by Lois M. Collins (with photos by Laura Seitz) about one of the first homeless hospices in the country: “The place where no one dies alone.” ([link removed])


** More resources for journalists
------------------------------------------------------------
* Meet Anderson Cooper at Poynter’s annual Bowtie Ball in Tampa, Florida, on Saturday, Nov. 18. Tickets are selling fast. Get yours today. ([link removed])
* Poynter’s Beat Academy (Webinar series) — Enroll now ([link removed]) .
* Poynter ACES Introductory Certificate in Editing (Online) — Enroll now ([link removed]) .
* Subscribe ([link removed]) to Poynter’s Friday newsletter, Open Tabs ([link removed]) with Poynter managing editor Ren LaForme, and get behind-the-scenes stories only available to subscribers.

Have feedback or a tip? Email Poynter senior media writer Tom Jones at [email protected] (mailto:[email protected]) .
[link removed]
I want more analysis of the news media to help me understand my world. ([link removed])
GIVE NOW ([link removed])

ADVERTISE ([link removed]) // DONATE ([link removed]) // LEARN ([link removed]) // JOBS ([link removed])
Did someone forward you this email? Sign up here. ([link removed])
[link removed] [link removed] [link removed] [link removed] mailto:[email protected]?subject=Feedback%20for%20Poynter
[link removed]
[link removed]
[link removed]
[link removed]
[link removed]
© All rights reserved Poynter Institute 2023
801 Third Street South, St. Petersburg, FL 33701
If you don't want to receive email updates from Poynter, we understand.
You can change your subscription preferences ([link removed]) or unsubscribe from all Poynter emails ([link removed]) .