[Homelessness and poverty are the tragic results of unfettered
capitalism and raging inequality, whether it’s in rural West
Virginia or in San Francisco’s Tenderloin. ]
[[link removed]]

THE CHARACTER ASSASSINATION OF SAN FRANCISCO  
[[link removed]]


 

Ari Paul
May 24, 2023
FAIR
[[link removed]]

*
[[link removed]]
*
[[link removed]]
*
*
[[link removed]]

_ Homelessness and poverty are the tragic results of unfettered
capitalism and raging inequality, whether it’s in rural West
Virginia or in San Francisco’s Tenderloin. _

,

 

CNN has joined the media chorus decrying the death of San Francisco
with a one-hour special (WHOLE STORY, 5/14/23
[[link removed]]).
On an episode hosted by Sara Sidner, the network declared that “the
city by the bay is now at the forefront of the nation’s
homelessness, mental illness and drug addiction crises,” while some
“residents worry Northern California’s largest municipality could
become a so-called failed city.”

The narrative of San Francisco’s demise has been building for some
time. In the corporate press, the closure of a Whole Foods
(NEWSWEEK, 4/11/23
[[link removed]]; ABC, 4/12/23
[[link removed]]; NEW
YORK TIMES, 4/30/23
[[link removed]])
is like the moment Afghans clung to a US Air Force plane
[[link removed]] as
the nation fell to the Taliban. The story of this store’s exit is
more complicated than criminal activity (48HILLS, 4/11/23
[[link removed]])—but
no matter, the narrative holds that permissive policies protecting the
homeless have allowed a zombie army of criminals to exert control over
the city, countered only by a police force that can do nothing,
Democratic politicians fearful to act and tech bosses cowering in
fear.

CNN has had some more reasonable coverage of the city in the past,
placing its crime statistics in a national context (4/7/23
[[link removed]])
and a fuller picture of why a much-hyped Nordstrom closure had less to
do with crime and more with general retail trends (5/3/23
[[link removed]]).

But in the lead-up to the documentary, CNN (5/14/23
[[link removed]])
also told a heart-wrenching story about a San Francisco mother who
lamented that the city’s policies led her son into drugs. She may
genuinely feel that way, but that doesn’t make it so: West Virginia
leads the nation in drug deaths (CBS, 8/2/22
[[link removed]]),
with more than three times
[[link removed]] the
per capita rate of California; why is there no media drumbeat against
Gov. Jim Justice?

‘NO ONE IS SAFE’

[Fox: Reporter calls San Francisco 'worse than the third world' due to
drugs, homeless problems]

_A local ABC reporter’s hyperbolic comment to CNN (5/14/23
[[link removed]])
becomes a FOX NEWS headline (5/15/23
[[link removed]])—because
it’s San Francisco._

It’s normal for the Rupert Murdoch–owned press (FOX NEWS, 5/11/23
[[link removed]], 5/15/23
[[link removed]]; WALL
STREET JOURNAL, 5/3/23
[[link removed]]; NEW
YORK POST, 5/4/23
[[link removed]])
to obsess about San Francisco falling apart. Tucker Carlson,
formerly FOX NEWS’ most-watched host and a San Francisco native,
ran a weeklong special on the city called “American Dystopia” (FOX
NEWS, 1/6/20
[[link removed]]),
which Media Matters for America (1/13/20
[[link removed]])
described as “dehumanizing homeless people.”

But this trend is embraced by the more centrist corporate press, too.
The NEW YORK TIMES gave space to venture capitalist Michael Moritz
(2/26/23
[[link removed]])
to lament the excesses of Democratic governance and repeatedly
eulogize the city’s retail establishments (12/17/22
[[link removed]], 2/9/23
[[link removed]], 4/30/23
[[link removed]]).

When tech boss Bob Lee was fatally stabbed near his home,
the TIMES (4/7/23
[[link removed]])
took at face value statements from fellow tech bosses about how he was
the victim of the out-of-control anarchy allowed by progressive
leaders. As it turned out, Lee was likely the victim of
sex-and-drug-fueled, tech boss–on–tech boss violence (NEW YORK
POST, 5/12/23
[[link removed]], 5/14/23
[[link removed]]).

In another example of media outlets showing their hand, CBS (4/7/23
[[link removed]])
reported, “A brutal and brazen attack on former San Francisco Fire
Commissioner Don Carmignani” left “him battling for his life and
neighbors on edge.” The person who had attacked the former commish
was unhoused, fueling the sentiment that the streets were filled with
roving sociopaths targeting people of all ranks, including civic
leaders. Along with the Lee killing, “both violent assaults have
ignited an intense debate over safety in the city.” The NEW YORK
POST (4/7/23
[[link removed]])
highlighted the attack as evidence that “no one is safe” in San
Francisco.

[NYT: Stabbing of Cash App Creator Raises Alarm, and Claims of
‘Lawless’ San Francisco]

_The NEW YORK TIMES (4/7/23
[[link removed]])
presented the stabbing of tech exec Bob Lee as a symbol of
“deepening frustration over the city’s homelessness
crisis”—before another “tech leader” was arrested for his
murder
[[link removed]]._

But as with the Lee story, the media assumptions were premature. Video
evidence later revealed that Carmignani had attacked the homeless man
with bear spray and that the homeless man acted in self-defense,
although Carmignani disputed this (CBS, 4/26/23
[[link removed]]; CNN, 4/27/23
[[link removed]]; LA
TIMES, 5/11/23
[[link removed]]).
In fact, lawyers for the homeless man in the case “alleged that
Carmignani may be involved in other incidents in which homeless people
were sprayed in the Cow Hollow and Marina District neighborhoods”
(NBC, 4/27/23
[[link removed]]). 
Carmignani also has his own checkered past: he resigned from his
commissioner post “one day after he was arrested in connection with
an alleged domestic violence incident” (SFGATE, 9/24/13
[[link removed]]).

At the ATLANTIC (6/8/22
[[link removed]]),
Nellie Bowles—a California heiress (SF CHRONICLE, 10/28/21
[[link removed]]; LA
TIMES, 6/14/22
[[link removed]]),
former NEW YORK TIMES writer
[[link removed]], and a participant in the
conservative and lucrative anti-woke propaganda network (DAILY
MAIL, 11/5/21
[[link removed]])—brought
an out-of-touch upper-class perspective to a San Francisco she,
like CNN, called a “failed city.” Her heart no doubt bleeds for
suffering people on the street, but she placed the blame on a regional
culture of permissiveness:

This approach to drug use and homelessness is distinctly San
Franciscan, blending empathy-driven progressivism with California
libertarianism. The roots of this belief system reach back to the
’60s, when hippies filled the streets with tents and weed. The city
has always had a soft spot for vagabonds, and an admirable focus on
care over punishment. Policy makers and residents largely embraced the
exciting idea that people should be able to do whatever they want to
do, including live in tent cities and have fun with drugs and make
their own medical decisions, even if they are out of their mind
sometimes.

‘FAILED CITY’

[Atlantic: How San Francisco Became a Failed City]

_San Francisco’s homicide rate has dropped by half
[[link removed]] since
the early 2000s—prompting the ATLANTIC (6/8/22
[[link removed]])
to run an essay on “How San Francisco Became a Failed City.”_

The casual use of the phrase “failed city” is insulting hyperbole.
The analogous term “failed state” was popularized in an early
’90s FOREIGN POLICY article (Winter/92–93
[[link removed]]), which
defined the “failed nation-state” as one “utterly incapable of
sustaining itself as a member of the international community”—a
definition that seems designed to invite intervention by said
“community.” (See UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO LAW REVIEW, Fall/05
[[link removed]].)
A failed state is a technical term for a place, due to internal
mismanagement and external pressure, where civil society has broken
down amid collapse in central governance. There is no major world body
that considers the loss of a Nordstrom store (SF CHRONICLE, 5/3/23
[[link removed]])
a valid metric of societal meltdown.

But even if we forgive journalists for their flexible poetic license,
the media narrative that San Francisco stands outside the US norm runs
contrary to reality.

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention data
[[link removed]] shows
that the highest rates of drug overdose mortality are in West
Virginia, Tennessee, Louisiana and Kentucky, with California far
behind. US Department of Agriculture research
[[link removed]] shows that the
highest poverty states are Louisiana, West Virginia, New Mexico and
Mississippi. FORBES’ list (1/31/23
[[link removed]])
of the most dangerous cities cites New Orleans, Detroit, St. Louis and
Memphis (as well as Mobile and Birmingham, Alabama), but not San
Francisco. San Francisco/Oakland does appear
[[link removed]] on the
list of cities with the highest homelessness rates—but seven cities
have higher rates, including New York City, Los Angeles and Las Vegas.

SURREAL MEDIA NARRATIVE

[KQED: Unhoused San Francisco Residents Sue City Over Displacement,
Rights Violations]

_Toro Castaño (KQED, 9/27/22
[[link removed]])
on homeless “sweeps”: “A lot of things they’re taking are warm
clothes, warm jackets, blankets, things that you need just to
survive.”_

It’s a surreal media narrative for Zal Shroff
[[link removed]], a senior attorney at the
Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights of the San Francisco Bay Area,
who recently helped win an injunction
[[link removed]] against
what the group calls the city’s discrimination against homelessness.
“On paper, the city has 3,000 shelter beds for 8,000 unhoused
people,” he told FAIR, noting that while residents may be frustrated
with street homelessness, there are often few places for the homeless
to go.

“There is no avenue for an unhoused person to seek shelter. You can
only get it after you’ve been harassed by police and beg for it,”
he said. “You can’t go to the police and ask, they have to
threaten you with citation and arrest, and then _maybe_ they’ll
ask to see if there is a shelter bed.”

Despite the media narrative about the city’s lawlessness, LCCRSF’s
summary of the lawsuit states
[[link removed]]—and
so far, one court agrees—that the city’s unhoused population are
subjected to “brutal policing practices that violate [their] civil
rights.” As Toro Castaño (48HILLS, 9/27/22
[[link removed]]),
who was homeless in the city from 2019 to 2021, told the court, “I
was harassed by San Francisco Police Department (SFPD) and Department
of Public Works (DPW) staff several times a week for the entirety of
the two years I was homeless.” He noted in the court papers that
while living on the street in May 2020, he was “harassed by police
officers from the Castro beat every day for five weeks.”

KQED (9/27/22
[[link removed]])
noted that “Castaño had his belongings taken from him by the city
four times during the pandemic, according to the complaint,” and
that “while Castaño was unhoused, he said he was asked to move
nearly every day.”

As Sarah Cronk, an unhoused person said in court papers, “If the
City does not have adequate shelter or housing for us, then it should
not be harassing us.” She and her partner “are just trying to
scrape by and build as much of a life for ourselves as possible—with
both dignity and safety,” Cronk said, but the city government
“makes that impossible for us.”

This is hardly the “lunatics are running the asylum” image the
media would have the public believe is the case.

For Shroff, the situation is frustrating, because while the injunction
is meant to stop police harassment of the homeless while encouraging
more affordable housing and shelter services, in the city’s
narrative, his organization is calling for outright anarchy (SF
CHRONICLE, 1/23/23
[[link removed]]; LAW360, 4/26/23
[[link removed]]). “That’s the narrative
that’s out there and is winning the day in the press,” he said,
“which is interesting, because we’re winning this case.”

MYTH OF SOARING CRIME

[San Francisco CA Murder/Homicide Rate 1999-2018]

_San Francisco did have a high murder rate in the early 2000s, but it
has since fallen dramatically, to close to the US and California
averages._

And then there’s the mythology of the city’s soaring crime. As
the SAN FRANCISCO STANDARD (12/22/22
[[link removed]])
reported, the city’s “crime totals cratered in 2020 when the city
hunkered down for the first waves of Covid,” and then rose again.
But “crime in San Francisco has not yet increased to pre-pandemic
levels—with a few key exceptions.”

The online news outlet said crime rates “have fallen tremendously
since peaks in the 1990s, which mirrors trends in cities across the
country,” and that the “city’s most recent crime spikes came in
2013 for violent crime and 2017 for property crime.” (To put this
admission into perspective, the STANDARD is financed by the
aforementioned Michael Moritz.)

SFGATE (1/7/22
[[link removed]])
also noted that violent crime rates in San Francisco matched national
trends, and were not national outliers. Despite ideas of the city’s
lawlessness and left-wing calls to “defund the police,” the “San
Francisco Police Department budget increased overall by 4.4% from 2019
to 2022” (KGO-TV, 10/13/22
[[link removed]]),
and Mayor London Breed has called for “a $27 million budget
supplemental to fund police overtime citywide” (KGO-TV, 3/8/23
[[link removed]]).
The right blamed the property crime spike on former District Attorney
Chesa Boudin, but with his recall (FAIR.ORG, 7/11/22
[[link removed]]),
there is no longer a George Soros–backed boogeyman to hold up as a
scapegoat (THE HILL, 6/9/22
[[link removed]]).

[SFGate: San Francisco Bay Area has the fastest growing economy in US,
report says]

_Oddly enough, the “failed city” has “the fastest growing
economy in US” (SFGATE, 11/16/22
[[link removed]])._

And while it is true that the city’s population has decreased (SF
CHRONICLE, 1/26/23
[[link removed]]),
the housing market is still hot, “with rents returning to pre-Covid
levels, and a median one-bedroom there now priced at $3,100 a month,
up 14% and the highest in two years” (BLOOMBERG, 7/26/22
[[link removed]]).
The city’s tourism economy is currently booming, after the pandemic
hurt the sector (SF CHRONICLE, 3/21/23
[[link removed]]).
The city’s unemployment rate had been sitting at a low 2.9%
[[link removed]] (KPIX-TV, 3/10/23
[[link removed]]; SF
CHRONICLE, 4/21/23
[[link removed]])
and has only recently spiked—not because of some progressive City
Hall policy, but thanks to nationwide layoffs in the locally
concentrated tech sector (SF CHRONICLE, 4/21/23
[[link removed]]).
One report (SFGATE, 11/16/22
[[link removed]])
showed that the “San Francisco Bay Area led the country in economic
growth in 2022, with a 4.8% increase in GDP.”

The skyrocketing wealth is connected to the homelessness problem,
Schroff said. While there is a mythology that street homelessness in
San Francisco is the result of outsiders traveling there for the
services and the mild weather, Schroff notes that LCCRSF research has
shown that a bulk of unhoused people are long-time area residents who
cannot find shelter.

The group’s lawsuit said “San Francisco failed to meet state
targets for affordable housing production between 1999 and
2014—ultimately constructing 61,000 fewer very low-income units than
needed.” From “2015 to 2022, the city only built 33% of the deeply
affordable housing units it promised, and only 25% of actual housing
production went to affordable housing.”

“The mental health services and the drug addiction services are
robust, but that doesn’t solve that two thirds of unhoused people
are reporting that they can’t find affordable housing,” Schroff
said. “There is no exit option.”

AMERICAN GOMORRAH

[NY Post: How ‘woke’ policies turned Downtown San Francisco into
an urban drug-den ]

_NEW YORK POST (10/15/22
[[link removed]]):
“San Francisco is governed by a leadership that is so enamored of
the city’s progressive, humanitarian self-image that the idea of
enforcing basic laws—even ones that save people’s lives like
controlling drug sales and consumption—has come to be regarded as
reactionary.”_

In a country where a state like Texas has seen six mass shootings this
year (USA TODAY, 5/8/23
[[link removed]]),
why is San Francisco the object of such obsession? The San Francisco
Bay Area, in the imagination of the American right, is the closest
thing America has to Sodom and Gomorrah. San Francisco is identified
as the epicenter of gay liberation, the home of the hippies, vegan
restaurants and streets where Cantonese and Spanish are heard as much
as English. Berkeley, just across the Bay, was a primary site of 1960s
student radicalism and counter-culture, and the flagship UC campus
continues to be a dreaded symbol of state-funded academic wokeness
(BERKELEYSIDE, 12/12/18
[[link removed]]; WASHINGTON
EXAMINER, 8/21/22
[[link removed]]; DAILY
BEAST, 10/31/22
[[link removed]]).

Affluenza has cleansed the Bay of much of its bohemia, but its
national political legacy lives on in Democratic establishment titans
like Nancy Pelosi and Dianne Feinstein. The area’s tech industry,
like Hollywood in the southern end of the state, is a lucrative
capitalist sector that the right, not incorrectly, associates with
Democratic voting (OPEN SECRETS, 1/12/21
[[link removed]]; WALL
STREET JOURNAL, 2/20/21
[[link removed]]).

So to paint San Francisco as an example of failed governance is, in
the right-wing narrative, to prove that the progressive urban
experiment has broadly failed. The Nazi Joseph Goebbels probably
didn’t [[link removed]] say,
“Repeat a lie often enough and it becomes the truth,” but it
remains a central principle of propaganda. The failure of San
Francisco has been a drumbeat in the conservative press, and as a
result, major corporate media are acting as if this is true, or at
least arguable. CNN, the NEW YORK TIMES and the ATLANTIC, by
buying into this mythology, are able to call into question compassion
for the homeless and alternatives to aggressive policing.

In fact, the WASHINGTON POST (5/21/19
[[link removed]])
seemed a little lonely in the corporate press when it argued that it
was an “earthquake of wealth” that permanently worsened the
city’s character, not the poor or any overly compassionate social
policy.

But all of the recent negative coverage surrounds the issue of
homeless people. Homelessness and poverty are the tragic results of
unfettered capitalism and raging inequality, whether it’s in rural
West Virginia or in San Francisco’s Tenderloin. Drug addiction is a
public health crisis that the US healthcare system neglects, like many
other ailments. These media pieces aren’t appalled by the conditions
that create seas of unhoused people, but are appalled that housed,
professional people have to deal with them. The NEW YORK
TIMES and CNN are in many ways different from FOX NEWS and
the NEW YORK POST, but this is where their worldviews meld.

This is media outrage focused not at systemic injustice, but based in
disgust at the victims of injustice.

_Ari Paul has reported for the NATION, the GUARDIAN, the FORWARD,
the BROOKLYN RAIL, VICE NEWS, IN THESE TIMES, JACOBIN and many
other outlets._

_FAIR’S WORK IS SUSTAINED BY OUR GENEROUS CONTRIBUTORS, WHO ALLOW US
TO REMAIN INDEPENDENT. DONATE
[[link removed]] TODAY TO BE A PART OF THIS
IMPORTANT MISSION._

_You can also support FAIR on Patreon! Click the button below!_

_[Become a patron at Patreon!]
[[link removed]]_

* homelessness
[[link removed]]
* poverty
[[link removed]]
* California
[[link removed]]
* addiction
[[link removed]]

*
[[link removed]]
*
[[link removed]]
*
*
[[link removed]]

 

 

 

INTERPRET THE WORLD AND CHANGE IT

 

 

Submit via web
[[link removed]]

Submit via email
Frequently asked questions
[[link removed]]

Manage subscription
[[link removed]]

Visit xxxxxx.org
[[link removed]]

Twitter [[link removed]]

Facebook [[link removed]]

 




[link removed]

To unsubscribe, click the following link:
[link removed]