[ Massive pay hikes and continued abuse of overtime pay send cop
salaries soaring while other city agencies are starved of funds. NYPD
officers are a big step closer to becoming members of the same 1% they
work for and protect.]
[[link removed]]

MAYOR ADAMS’ IRRESPONSIBLE NEW POLICE-UNION CONTRACT DEMANDS CLOSER
SCRUTINY  
[[link removed]]


 

John Teufel
April 12, 2023
The Indypendent
[[link removed]]


*
[[link removed]]
*
[[link removed]]
*
*
[[link removed]]

_ Massive pay hikes and continued abuse of overtime pay send cop
salaries soaring while other city agencies are starved of funds. NYPD
officers are a big step closer to becoming members of the same 1% they
work for and protect. _

An army of NYPD faces off against Black Lives Matter protesters.,
Photo: Sue Brisk. / The Indypendent

 

They aren’t quite there yet — the 1% is really rich! But thanks to
the new contract deal Eric Adams has struck with the PBA, members of
the force with at least five years on the job could easily see
themselves spring into the top 10% of earners nationwide if they are
willing to hit the gas on overtime.

Let’s crunch some numbers. The new deal, which runs retroactively
from 2017 to 2025, sees officers with five and a half years on the job
hit a base salary of $130,000, a pay bump of about 50% from current
five-year officers. Overtime, which for NYPD officers is any time
worked over 40 hours a week, gets paid out at time-and-a-half. Even
with the present, much lower salaries, Legal Aid’s Law Enforcement
Lookup tool
[[link removed]] reveals that
thousands of cops have managed to top $50,000 in annual overtime at
some point in the last three years, and many have gone way above that,
earning $70,000 or $80,000 or more on top of their normal salaries.

Let me now stretch the limits of my abilities and try to do some math
to show you how overtime at a higher wage is much more valuable than
overtime at a lower wage. If you assume an officer is making $84,000 a
year, which is approximately the current five-year officer salary,
that works out to around $40 an hour (not counting vacation and sick
time). Overtime at that rate is $60 an hour. The new five-year salary,
on an hourly basis and again without including vacation and sick time,
is $62.50 (incredibly, more than the current overtime rate). That
means the new overtime rate for five-year cops will be a whopping
$93.75 an hour, a 50% increase. An officer who pulled $50,000 in
overtime under the old contract will now make $75,000 in overtime
alone for the same number of hours, on top of their newly bloated
salary. (It’s easy for cops to create unnecessary overtime –
officers themselves call it, in a somewhat visually disgusting
euphemism, “milking it
[[link removed]].”)

COPS ROUTINELY RETIRE IN THEIR MID-40S WITH A GOLD-PLATED PENSION THAT
IS JUICED BY THEIR ABILITY TO RACK UP OVERTIME HOURS IN THEIR FINAL
THREE YEARS ON THE FORCE. 

You have to make $173,176
[[link removed]] a
year to make it into the top 10% of earners in the United States. This
new contract will place a lot of rank-and-file cops deep into that ten
percent.

Cops already enjoy arguably the sweetest perks in the New York City
civil-servant firmament. After 22 years of work, they retire with a
pension worth 50% of their annual salary, which is calculated to
include their overtime pay. (They can retire at 20 years with a
slightly smaller pension.) Even under the current contract, retired
NYPD officers can go on to become quite well-off by taking up second
careers, often in lucrative private security positions, where they are
able to formalize their informal prior job of protecting rich
peoples’ stuff. In the past, this generous retirement program (which
sees some officers retire with full pension at age 43) was in theory
meant to make up for lower pay. Now that officers will earn more than
most other civil servants in the city, it is simply a gratuity,
another example of how the PBA has New Yorkers over the barrel.

And of course, NYPD police enjoy a perk that could be described
alternately as sweet or mind-numbingly horrifying — they can commit
egregious misconduct in the line of duty, up to and including murder,
without facing any consequences.

It is both a cliché and false to say that budgets express our
priorities “as a city” — they express the priorities of the
small number of people who vote them into law. But boy oh boy, are
those people’s priorities whacked. Teachers with five years on the
job and a Masters degree earn $71,290 a year, more than $50,000 less
than cops under the new deal. And cops don’t have to have a Masters,
or a Bachelors for that matter. Teachers aren’t eligible for
overtime. Even if you prorate that pay to factor in summers off —
that is, if you increase that teacher’s salary by 25% to account for
June through August off — they come in over $30,000 less than cops.
And they have to deal with demanding kids all day, whereas cops get to
play Candy Crush on their phones with their pals. (Believe me, with
clearance rates like this
[[link removed]],
they ain’t out there solving murders.) Also, I don’t know of any
cops who have to buy their own guns, as teachers often do school
supplies.

As an attorney, when I read about the latest Eric Adams-created
outrage, my mind automatically goes to a simple question: How is he
legally able to do this? In this case, I wondered whether Adams has
the sole legal authority to obligate the City to this massive
payout, estimated to cost NYC taxpayers $5.5 billion
[[link removed]] over
and above the massive sums we already hand over to the NYPD. Can he
just…do that?

The answer is yes and no. I know, I know. Stick with me.

The New York Civil Service Law (known as the “Taylor Law”) does
exclusively vest the power to negotiate and enter into labor
agreements with local chief executives, usually mayors. That is state
law — New York City can’t do anything about it. When it comes to
signing contracts with unions, Eric Adams is the only game in town.

But that doesn’t mean the City Council is obligated to fund those
contracts. As the man who recently secured the winning bid to own the
Flatiron Building
[[link removed]],
only to fail to make the down payment knows, it is one thing to sign a
piece of paper and another to come up with the cash obligated thereon.

The City Council does not need to agree to a budget that incorporates
this irresponsible, inequitable contract. Certainly it doesn’t need
to do so without extracting some other serious concessions from the
mayor and the NYPD, which off the top of my head could include
disbanding the Strategic Response Group
[[link removed]],
reining in overtime spending, taking cops off mental health calls and
removing final disciplinary authority from the police commissioner. 

THIS NEW CONTRACT WILL PLACE A LOT OF RANK-AND-FILE COPS DEEP INTO THE
TOP 10% OF EARNERS IN THE UNITED STATES. 

Such an action wouldn’t be unprecedented. In 2004, the Buffalo
legislature knocked down
[[link removed]] a
proposed police contract over concerns about healthcare costs. In
2017, Rockland County legislators fought
[[link removed]] their
county executive (the Rockland version of a mayor) over how to pay for
a sheriff’s union contract. Outside of New York, Denver legislators
were brave enough to reject
[[link removed]] their
own police union’s contract in 2020. 

If ever a contract needed to be smothered in the crib, it is this one.
Eric Adams has been slicing and dicing New York City government with
aplomb, first targeting the school system
[[link removed]] and
now moving on to demand 4% cuts from the budgets of nearly every city
agency
[[link removed]].
Particularly gruesome, for someone who spent a lot of time in
libraries as a kid, are the tens of millions
[[link removed]] he
is trying to cut from the City’s library funding. To reward the NYPD
— an agency that has not only actively failed in its mission to
reduce crime but has taken a lot of innocent victims down along the
way — while punishing every other New Yorker with cuts to vital
services, would be to roll over and die. 

If that happens, we may as well disband the City Council now and admit
that Adams is, as he so often claims, an emissary of God among us, and
we live not in a city, but in a police department with some minimal
public services attached.

_THE INDYPENDENT IS A NEW YORK CITY-BASED NEWSPAPER
[[link removed]] AND WEBSITE. OuR INDEPENDENT,
GRASSROOTS JOURNALISM IS MADE POSSIBLE BY READERS LIKE YOU. PLEASE
CONSIDER MAKING A RECURRING OR ONE-TIME DONATION
[[link removed]] TODAY OR SUBSCRIBE
[[link removed]] TO OUR MONTHLY PRINT EDITION AND
GET EVERY COPY SENT STRAIGHT TO YOUR HOME. _

* New York City
[[link removed]]
* Mayor Eric Adams
[[link removed]]
* New York City Council
[[link removed]]
* NYPD
[[link removed]]
* Police
[[link removed]]
* police budgets
[[link removed]]
* budget cuts
[[link removed]]
* New York labor unions
[[link removed]]
* Labor Unions
[[link removed]]
* Municipal Labor Committee
[[link removed]]
* New York City Unions
[[link removed]]

*
[[link removed]]
*
[[link removed]]
*
*
[[link removed]]

 

 

 

INTERPRET THE WORLD AND CHANGE IT

 

 

Submit via web
[[link removed]]

Submit via email
Frequently asked questions
[[link removed]]

Manage subscription
[[link removed]]

Visit xxxxxx.org
[[link removed]]

Twitter [[link removed]]

Facebook [[link removed]]

 




[link removed]

To unsubscribe, click the following link:
[link removed]